A critical exploration of inclusion policies of elite UK universities

Abstract

Inclusion is seen as an ethical obligation, grounded in notions of equity and social justice for all groups and at all stages of education, with higher education (HE) representing a distinctive space where the inclusion agenda is becoming more influential. However, inclusion is also increasingly recognised as an ambiguous concept that might have lost its critical edge and is in many cases reduced to 'chatter'. To explore inclusion in this context, we analysed 48 policy documents from the websites of the 24 Russell Group Universities (the 'elite', research-intensive, UK universities) using a critical discourse analysis approach. We found that inclusion was rarely defined clearly, and that tensions, complexity and pedagogical implications of inclusion were not discussed. Inclusion was also related to excellence and ideas about a 'global university' that are central to a university's reputation and ability to attract international students and staff. We see three ways in which these findings are significant: the way inclusion was approached in the policy documents could largely be described as managerial/legalistic, seen as the responsibility of human resources; inclusion was perceived as an act of legal compliance that was also expected to influence everyday relationships -but without an explanation of

Facilitadores para la Inclusión: Claves para el Éxito Universitario

“…Las universidades tienen la responsabilidad de repensar sus culturas, políticas y prácticas para que la inclusión sea real y que todas las personas, sin excepción, puedan sentirse realmente reconocidas y bienvenidas, aprendan, participen y tengan éxito (Koutsouris et al, 2022;Lourens y Swartz, 2019;Padilla et al, 2022). Sin embargo, los estudios revelan que las barreras aún persisten en la Educación Superior (Collins et al, 2018;González-Castellano et al, 2021;Medina-García et al, 2021).…”

Poverty, ACEs and stigmatised places: The application of psychology to the challenges of disadvantage

“…Instead, we seem to take strides in the wrong direction, enhancing the exclusionary nature of education with the winds of political decision‐making behind us. Instead of opening up education, we have seen ever‐increasing student fees and a failure by many Russell Group universities to effectively recruit and retain students from disadvantaged contexts (Koutsouris et al, 2022).…”

A Systematic Review of the Benefits and Challenges of Technologies for the Learning of University Students With Disabilities

“…The number of people from vulnerable groups accessing university, including individuals with disabilities, is increasing (Koutsouris et al, 2022). Accessing and completing a higher education degree has been found to be linked to improving the educational, social, employment and life opportunities of students with disabilities (Villouta & Villarreal, 2022).…”

“…For example, data from the latest OECD Education at a Glance report (OECD, 2021) show that people who have a higher education degree can earn, on average, 38% more than their peers who have not studied at university. Undoubtedly, higher education institutions' inclusion, equity and diversity policies play a key role in accessing and successfully completing university degrees (Koutsouris et al, 2022). However, studies conclude that barriers to inclusion are still present in universities around the world (Villouta & Villarreal, 2022).…”

“…Undoubtedly, higher education institutions' inclusion, equity and diversity policies play a key role in accessing and successfully completing university degrees (Koutsouris et al, 2022). However, studies conclude that barriers to inclusion are still present in universities around the world (Villouta & Villarreal, 2022).…”