A critical radius for unit Hopf vector fields on spheres

Abstract

The volume of a unit vector field V of the sphere S n (n odd) is the volume of its image V (S n ) in the unit tangent bundle. Unit Hopf vector fields, that is, unit vector fields that are tangent to the fibre of a Hopf fibration S n → CP n−1 2 , are well known to be critical for the volume functional. Moreover, Gluck and Ziller proved that these fields achieve the minimum of the volume if n = 3 and they opened the question of whether this result would be true for all odd dimensional spheres. It was shown to be inaccurate on spheres of radius one. Indeed, Pedersen exhibited smooth vector fields on the unit sphere with less volume than Hopf vector fields for a dimension greater than five. In this article, we consider the situation for any odd dimensional spheres, but not necessarily of radius one. We show that the stability of the Hopf field actually depends on radius, instability occurs precisely if and only if r > 1 √ n−4 . In particular, the Hopf field cannot be minimum in this range. On the contrary, for r small, a computation shows that the volume of vector fields built by Pedersen is greater than the volume of the Hopf one thus, in this case, the Hopf vector field remains a candidate to be a minimizer. We then study the asymptotic behaviour of the volume; for small r it is ruled by the first term of the Taylor expansion of the volume. We call this term the twisting of the vector field. The lower this term is, the lower the volume of the vector field is for small r. It turns out that unit Hopf vector fields are absolute minima of the twisting. This fact, together with the stability result, gives two positive arguments in favour of the Gluck and Ziller conjecture for small r.

Area-minimizing vector fields on round 2-spheres

“…One of the intriguing points of the Gluck and Ziller problem is the dependence on dilatations of the metric [2]. The reason is that a dilatation on the base manifold produces dilatations with di¤erent rates on horizontal or vertical distributions of the tangent bundle.…”

A topological minorization for the volume of vector fields on 5-manifolds

“…In [1] and [6] respectively, we can find a version concerning spheres of radius r for each sense of the implication of Theorem 1 mentioned in the Introduction. Recall that the study of unit vector fields on the sphere of curvature c, S n ( 1 √ c ), is equivalent to the study of fields with length 1 √ c on S n (1).…”

“…Recall that the study of unit vector fields on the sphere of curvature c, S n ( 1 √ c ), is equivalent to the study of fields with length 1 √ c on S n (1). For this reason, in this issue, assumptions concerning the length of the vector field and the curvature of the manifold should not look strange, as in Theorem 4.…”

Volume, energy and generalized energy of unit vector fields on Berger spheres: stability of Hopf vector fields

“…Nevertheless, concerning the stability of Hopf vector fields as critical points of the volume it has been shown [1,7] that for m > 1 they are unstable if and only if the curvature is lower than 2m − 3. Nevertheless, concerning the stability of Hopf vector fields as critical points of the volume it has been shown [1,7] that for m > 1 they are unstable if and only if the curvature is lower than 2m − 3.…”