Background: Abortive cycling is a key feature of RNA polymerases. Results: Nicks and mismatches have little effect on abortive probabilities.
Conclusion:The energetics of the hybrid pushing on the protein, rather than that of bubble expansion, is the primary contributor to abortive cycling. Significance: Abortive cycling arises from the need to couple RNA growth to promoter release in RNA polymerases.It has long been known that during initial transcription of the first 8 -10 bases of RNA, complexes are relatively unstable, leading to the release of short abortive RNA transcripts. An early "stressed intermediate" model led to a more specific mechanistic model proposing "scrunching" stress as the basis for the instability. Recent studies in the single subunit T7 RNA polymerase have argued against scrunching as the energetic driving force and instead argue for a model in which pushing of the RNA-DNA hybrid against a protein element associated with promoter binding, while likely driving promoter release, reciprocally leads to instability of the hybrid. In this study, we test these models in the structurally unrelated multisubunit bacterial RNA polymerase. Via the targeted introduction of mismatches and nicks in the DNA, we demonstrate that neither downstream bubble collapse nor compaction/scrunching of either the single-stranded template or nontemplate strands is a major force driving abortive instability (although collapse from the downstream end of the bubble does contribute significantly to the instability of artificially halted complexes). In contrast, pushing of the hybrid against a mobile protein element ( 3.2 in the bacterial enzyme) results in substantially increased abortive instability and is likely the primary energetic contributor to abortive cycling. The results suggest that abortive instability is a by-product of the mechanistic need to couple the energy of nucleotide addition (RNA chain growth) to driving the timed release of promoter contacts during initial transcription.Abortive cycling, marked by the premature release of short RNA products from initially transcribing complexes, is a common feature in all RNA polymerases (1-3) and is known to be a point of cellular regulation at some promoters (4). Over the last decade, abortive cycling has been extensively studied, and various models have been proposed to explain its occurrence (5-7).Prior to the initiation of transcription, an RNA polymerase must melt open the promoter DNA to form an open complex. The initial bubble in the open complex is 13-14 base pairs (bp) long for Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (8, 9), about 8 bp for RNA polymerase II (10), and about 8 bp for T7 RNA polymerase (11-13). RNA polymerases can accommodate only a 2-3-nucleotide transcript in their open complex (14), and to continue beyond that requires further melting of downstream DNA while maintaining promoter contacts, and by keeping the upstream edge of the bubble constant, the bubble expands. Not surprisingly, then, RNA polymerases maintain their initial promoter contacts thr...