A Data-Driven Approach to Development of a Taxonomy Framework for Triple Bottom Line Metrics

Abstract

This paper proposes a data-driven approach to develop a taxonomy in a data structure on list for triple bottom line (TBL) metrics. The approach is built from the authors reflection on the subject and review of the literature about TBL. The envisaged taxonomy framework grid to be developed through this approach will enable existing metrics to be classified, grouped, and standardized, as well as detect the need for further metrics development in uncovered domains and applications. The approach reported aims at developing a taxonomy structure that can be seen as a bi-dimensional table focusing on feature interrogations and characterizing answers, which will be the basis on which the taxonomy can then be developed. The interrogations column is designed as the stack of the TBL metrics features: What type of metric is it (qualitative, quantitative, or hybrid)? What is the level of complexity of the problems where it is used? What standards does it follow? How is the measurement made, and what are the techniques that it uses? In what kinds of problems, subjects, and domains is the metric used? How is the metric validated? What is the method used in its calculation? The column of characterizing answers results from a categorization of the range of types of answers to the feature interrogations. The approach reported in this paper is based on a screening tool that searches and analyzes information both within abstracts and full-text journal papers. The vision for this future taxonomy is that it will enable locating for any specific context, discern what TBL metrics are used in that context or similar contexts, or whether there is a lack of developed metrics. This meta knowledge will enable a conscious decision to be made between creating a new metric or using one of those that already exists. In this latter case, it would also make it possible to choose, among several metrics, the one that is most appropriate to the context at hand. In addition, this future framework will ease new future literature revisions, when these are viewed as updates of this envisaged taxonomy. This would allow creating a dynamic taxonomy for TBL metrics. This paper presents a computational approach to develop such taxonomy, and reports on the initial steps taken in that direction, by creating a taxonomy framework grid with a computational approach.

Emergence fostered by systemic analysis—Seeding innovation for sustainable development

“…Another key reference typically used is the triple bottom line (TBL), featuring social, environmental (ecological), and economic dimensions, or pillars, of sustainability (Elkington, 1997). TBL offered a guideline for an economically sustainable strategy in organizations, and for explicitly targeted environmental and social sustainability strategies (Vieira et al, 2019). However, constant flux is expected due to social, political, economic, and environmental pressures (Martens & Carvalho, 2017).…”

Emergence Aiming Innovation for Sustainability

“…The triple bottom line (TBL) essentially serves the purpose of a guideline according to which organizations develop and implement not only a traditional economically sustainable strategy, but also explicitly include strategies for environmental and social sustainability [6]. However, the three pillars are expected to be in a constant flux due to social, political, economic and environmental pressures [7].…”

Electrification of Highway Transportation with Solar and Wind Energy

“…Called vehicle-to-grid (V2G) [15,16], this is an emerging technology, which is expected to improve power grid utilization by a better balancing power supply with actual demand. Therefore, BEVs can bring various benefits to the economy, environment and society, that is, the "triple bottom line" of sustainable development [17,18]. As the major concerns surrounding their convenience of use, especially limited driving range and restricted battery charging locations, are being and will continue to be improved, BEVs are arguably a very attractive substitute for conventional ICEVs.…”