A data envelopment analysis (DEA) model for building energy benchmarking

Abstract

Purpose Building energy benchmarking is required for adopting an energy certification scheme, promoting energy efficiency and reducing energy consumption. It demonstrates the current level of energy consumption, the value of potential energy improvement and the prospects for additional savings. This paper aims to create a new data envelopment analysis (DEA) model that overcomes the limitations of existing models for building energy benchmarking. Design/methodology/approach Data preparation: the findings of the literature search and subject matter experts’ inputs are used to construct the DEA model. Particularly, it is ensured that the included variables would not violate the fundamental assumption of DEA modeling, DEA convexity axiom. New DEA formulation: controllable and non-controllable variables, e.g. weather conditions, are differentiated in the new formulation. A new approach is used to identify outliers to avoid skewing the efficiency scores for the rest of the buildings under consideration. Efficiency analysis: three distinct efficiencies are computed and analyzed in benchmarking building energy: overall, pure technical, and scale efficiency. Findings The proposed DEA approach is successfully applied to a data set provided by a utility management and energy services company that is active in the multifamily housing industry. Building characteristics and energy consumption of 124 multifamily properties in 15 different states in the USA are found in the data set. Buildings in this data set are benchmarked using the new DEA energy benchmarking formulation. Building energy benchmarking is also conducted in a time series manner showing how a particular building performs across the period of 12 months compared with its peers. Originality/value The proposed research contributes to the body of knowledge in building energy benchmarking through developing a new outlier detection method to mitigate the impact of super-efficient and super-inefficient buildings on skewing the efficiency scores of the other buildings; avoiding ratio variables in the DEA formulation to adhere to the convexity assumption that existing DEA methods do not follow; and distinguishing between controllable and non-controllable variables in the DEA formulation. This research contributes to the state of practice through providing a new energy benchmarking tool for facility managers and building owners that strive to relatively rank the energy-efficiency of their properties and identify low-performing properties as investment targets to enhance energy efficiency.

Revisiting the Efficiency of Indian Banking Sector: An Analysis of Comparative Models Through Data Envelopment Analysis

“…DEA has been implemented to measure the performance of many other industries such as railways (Kwak et al, 2016;George & Rangaraj, 2008); hospitals (Sharma & Dipasha, 2018); Airport (Keskin & Köksal, 2019); schools (Mante & O'Brien, 2002); communication (Kwon et al, 2008;Sigala, 2003); Retail distribution network (Lau, 2012); Environment (Mehta et al, 2019); and Energy (Ashuri et al, 2019) etc.…”

Application of Dea in Benchmarking: A Systematic Literature Review From 2003–2020

“…Nevertheless, regarding the interval scale data, such a concept would be highly advantageous in discovering the targeted units. Ashuri et al (2019) contributed to our information in creating the energy benchmarking using the modern DEA model. This modern DEA model has been utilized for benchmarking the energy efficiency in 108 buildings in a multi-family sector that considered parameters showing the total consumption of energy, building properties as well as local weather condition.…”

Assess the Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic and Propose Solutions for Sustainable Development for Textile Enterprises: An Integrated Data Envelopment Analysis-Binary Logistic Model Approach

“…DEA models and binary logistic models have been widely used and applied in many fields of science, engineering, and the world economy (Kwon 2014;Wong and Wong 2007;Ashuri et al 2019;Pourmahmoud and Azad 2021;Aparicio 2016). However, no scientific study has combined DEA and Binary logistic models to assess the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and to identify sustainable development solutions for textile enterprises.…”