Background
The number of simultaneous liver-kidney transplants has significantly increased in the United States. There has also been an increase in kidney-after-liver transplants associated with 2017 policy revisions aimed to fairly allocate kidneys after livers. Simultaneous liver-kidney and kidney-after-liver candidates are prioritized in allocation policy for kidney offers ahead of kidney-alone candidates.
Methods
We compared kidney graft outcomes of kidney-alone transplant recipients to simultaneous liver-kidney and kidney-after-liver transplants using paired kidney models to mitigate differences among donor risk factors. We evaluated recipient characteristics between transplant types and calculated differential graft years using restricted mean survival estimates.
Results
We evaluated 3053 paired donors to kidney-alone and simultaneous liver-kidney recipients and 516 paired donors to kidney-alone and kidney-after-liver recipients from 8/2017-8/2022. Kidney-alone recipients were younger, more likely on dialysis and Black race. One and three-year post-transplant kidney graft survival for kidney-alone recipients was (94% and 86%) vs. simultaneous liver-kidney recipients(89% and 80%,respectively,p<0.001). One and three-year kidney graft survival for kidney-alone recipients was (94% and 84%) vs. kidney-after-liver recipients (93% and 87%,respectively,p=0.53). The additional kidney graft years for kidney-alone vs simultaneous liver-kidney transplants was 21 graft years/100 transplants(standard error=5.0) within four-years post-transplantation with no significant difference between kidney-after-liver and kidney-alone transplants.
Conclusions
Over a five-year period in the US, simultaneous liver-kidney transplantation was associated with significantly lower kidney graft survival compared to paired kidney-alone transplants. Most differences in graft survival between simultaneous liver-kidney and kidney-alone transplants occurred within the first-year post-transplantation. In contrast, kidney-after-liver transplants had comparable graft survival to paired kidney-alone transplants.