Due to the sensitivity of sandy soil’s mechanical behavior to the particle shape, it is thus of importance for interpreting the effect of particle shape on the ground response induced by tunnel excavation in sandy formations. We conducted a series of 2D DEM (discrete element method) simulations on a common circular tunnel excavation in sandy soil with variable-shaped particles, which are characterized as two descriptors, i.e., aspect ratio (AR) and convexity (C). The macroscopic responses and the microscopic characteristics of the sandy ground are elaborated in detail. The simulation results show obvious asymmetrical features of the excavated ground, which results from the ground heterogeneity caused by the irregular particle shape. In addition, we investigate the roles of AR and C on the ground response and find that reducing AR or increasing C will enlarge the ground settlement, i.e., the sandy ground deformation is more sensitive to the particles with more irregular shapes. However, elongated particles are beneficial for the generation of soil arching with stronger bearing capacity and thus reduce the soil pressure on the tunnel lining. Our findings have important implications for the safety assessment of the tunnel excavation, as well as other underground structure construction in sandy formations.