A Field Study on the Use of Process Mining of Event Logs as an Analytical Procedure in Auditing

Abstract

There is a large body of accounting research literature examining the use of analytical procedures by auditors and proposing either new types of analytical procedures or more effective ways of implementing existing procedures. In this paper, we demonstrate-using procurement data from a leading global bank-the value added in an audit setting of a new type of analytical procedure: process mining of event logs. In particular, using process mining, we are able to identify numerous transactions that we consider to be audit-relevant information, including payments made without approval, violations of segregation of duty controls, and violations of company-specific internal procedures. Furthermore, these identified anomalies were not detected by the bank's internal auditors when they conducted their examination of that same data using conventional audit procedures, thus establishing the benefits of using process mining to complement existing audit methods. Process mining is a very different approach to evidence collection and analysis as it does not focus on the value of transactions and its aggregations, but on the transactional processes themselves. In addition to demonstrating the benefits of process mining in an audit context, this paper also discusses the contributions that process mining can make both to accounting research and auditing practice.

Autoencoder Neural Networks versus External Auditors: Detecting Unusual Journal Entries in Financial Statement Audits

“…A subsequent paper proposed a bipartite model based on extreme value theory and Bayesian analysis to detect journal entries with a low probability of causing a material misstatement [26]. Another stream of literature focusses on business processes and the application of process mining to identify unusual or not well-controlled process instances from ERP system data [27,28]. Schreyer et al described one of the few attempts to apply deep learning in the context of auditing [29].…”

Call for Papers, Issue 5/2021

“…Van der Aalst et al (2007) were the first ones to discuss process mining from the perspective of applications in industrial practice. Jans et al (2014) applied process mining techniques to enrich audit evidence during a financial statement audit. Vom Brocke and Mendling (2018) present various applications of process mining in hospitals, insurances, software usability analysis, and logistics.…”

The Effect of Continuous Auditing, Role Duality, and Organizational Identification on the Incidence and Likelihood of Reporting Management Opportunism

“…Audit practitioners and other stakeholders suggest that CA affords the IA function many benefits (Jans, Alles, and Vasarhelyi 2014) such as shorter audit cycle times and increased interactions with managers. 1 These benefits suggest that use of CA could result in less opportunism (PwC 2006; AICPA 2012b) due to management's need to more frequently explain significant audit findings to senior management and/or the audit committee (Barr-Pulliam 2017).…”