A food systems approach and qualitative system dynamics model to reveal policy issues within the commercial broiler chicken system in South Africa

Abstract

Global broiler production and consumption levels continue to rise. South Africa’s broiler system is dominated by commercial production and formal retail trade, with competition from cheap imports. Local broiler policies have narrow, production-driven, short-term aims for industry growth and national food security. However, these have unintended consequences that undermine the system’s future sustainability. Using a food systems approach, this study developed a qualitative system dynamics model of the South African commercial broiler system and used it to engage stakeholders in policy discussions within the boundaries of health, nutrition, and environmental sustainability. A problem statement and key system elements were drawn from a previously published qualitative study and were validated by 15 stakeholders via an online questionnaire. From this, a seed model was developed, expanded into a larger model, and shared in a modular format with stakeholders in virtual meetings, on an individual or institutional basis, for feedback and validation, and for discussion of areas for policy consideration. Refinements were incorporated into the modules, policy considerations were summarised, and crosscutting issues were identified. The model demonstrated the system’s complexity, interlinkages, feedbacks, reinforcing and balancing loops, and behaviour archetypes. The modular presentation format created a suitable platform for stakeholder engagement. Current policies focus on local commercial production, formal markets, and affordability without cognisance of the broader system represented by the model. Inequality pervades throughout the system. Commercial producers, linked to large supermarkets and fast-food chains, dominate the system, presenting barriers to entry. Affordability is unintentionally traded off against non-communicable disease risks through brining of most frozen products, and ultra-processing of fast-food items. Foodborne disease control is critical, given the proportion of vulnerable individuals, and greater coherence of food safety policy is urgently needed. The environmental footprint of broilers, whilst less than that of ruminants, deserves closer scrutiny based on its dependence on intensive cereal production for feed. This study’s food systems approach provides a system-wide perspective and a foundation for policymakers to develop more integrated and transformative policies.

System dynamics model for an agile pharmaceutical supply chain during COVID‑19 pandemic in Iran

“…Creating feedback loops provides information on a strategy’s performance and potential consequences in the system dynamics method [ 76 , 77 ]. The conclusion drawn from the causal loop diagram’s positive and negative loops is that changes in one element in a cycle may be identified as having an impact on another factor, leading to a greater knowledge of the system’s performance and feedback.…”

Integrating climate change, food safety, nutrition, and health outcomes in food systems policies and programs in Africa

“…Second, the study analyzes policy documents, strategic plans, and program reports related to climate change adaptation, food safety regulations, nutrition initiatives, and public health interventions in Africa, following Queenan et al (2022) and Nordhagen et al (2022), to identify existing policy frameworks, institutional arrangements, implementation strategies, and food safety challenges as the well as areas for improvement. Third, the study analyzes selected case studies from different African countries that exemplify successful integration of climate change considerations into food safety, nutrition, and health policies and programs (Aworh, 2021; McCann et al, 2023; Queenan et al, 2022). This is important to highlight innovative approaches, best practices, and lessons learned that can inform policy development and implementation in this context.…”

Untitled

“…K. Queenan et al (2022) noted that the use of developed and implemented probiotics in the field of broiler chickens is caused by the growing problem of antibiotic-resistant microorganisms. Therefore, in broiler production, it is necessary to implement food safety and quality control systems for broiler chickens, including traceability systems and hazard analysis systems at critical control points, and to consider the health of the bird, quality feeding, and environmental sustainability.…”