A Formal Representation of the WHO and UNICEF Estimates of National Immunization Coverage: A Computational Logic Approach

Abstract

Production of official statistics frequently requires expert judgement to evaluate and reconcile data of unknown and varying quality from multiple and potentially conflicting sources. Moreover, exceptional events may be difficult to incorporate in modelled estimates. Computational logic provides a methodology and tools for incorporating analyst's judgement, integrating multiple data sources and modelling methods, ensuring transparency and replicability, and making documentation computationally accessible. Representations using computational logic can be implemented in a variety of computer-based languages for automated production. Computational logic complements standard mathematical and statistical techniques and extends the flexibility of mathematical and statistical modelling. A basic overview of computational logic is presented and its application to official statistics is illustrated with the WHO & UNICEF estimates of national immunization coverage.

Global estimates of human papillomavirus vaccination coverage by region and income level: a pooled analysis

“…Surveys and nonofficial sources could identify those cases. 37 Our coverage estimates were usually extracted from only one source. When additional sources were available, few discrepancies were found and official estimates were commonly selected.…”

Think globally, act locally: the role of local demographics and vaccination coverage in the dynamic response of measles infection to control

“…WHO derived coverage estimates for the first routine dose of measles containing vaccine (MCV1) from reported coverage data and survey results by use of computational logic [36]. …”

A Mathematical Model for Control and Elimination of the Transmission Dynamics of Measles

“…Measles cases and vaccination coverage are reported annually to WHO by all member states through the WHO/ UNICEF Joint Reporting Form [4]. WHO derived coverage estimates for the first routine dose of Measles-Containing Vaccine (MCV1) from reported coverage data and survey results by use of computational logic [5]. Measles cases reported through surveillance systems typically represent a fraction of the true number of cases because many children do not present for medical attention and when medical care is sought, cases can be misdiagnosed or not reported to central authorities [6].…”

“…Now, the matrix ) 5; is known as the next-generation matrix. The largest eigenvalue or spectral radius ) 5; of is the effective reproduction number of the model.…”