Genomic analyses have proliferated without being tied to tangible phenotypes. For example, although coordination of both gene expression and genetic linkage have been offered as genetic mechanisms for the frequently observed clustering of genes participating in fungal metabolic pathways, elucidation of the phenotype(s) favored by selection, resulting in cluster formation and maintenance, has not been forthcoming. We noted that the cause of certain well-studied human metabolic disorders is the accumulation of toxic intermediate compounds (ICs), which occurs when the product of an enzyme is not used as a substrate by a downstream neighbor in the metabolic network. This raises the hypothesis that the phenotype favored by selection to drive gene clustering is the mitigation of IC toxicity. To test this, we examined 100 diverse fungal genomes for the simplest type of cluster, gene pairs that are both metabolic neighbors and chromosomal neighbors immediately adjacent to each other, which we refer to as "double neighbor gene pairs" (DNGPs). Examination of the toxicity of their corresponding ICs shows that, compared with chromosomally nonadjacent metabolic neighbors, DNGPs are enriched for ICs that have acutely toxic LD 50 doses or reactive functional groups. Furthermore, DNGPs are significantly more likely to be divergently oriented on the chromosome; remarkably, ∼40% of these DNGPs have ICs known to be toxic. We submit that the structure of synteny in metabolic pathways of fungi is a signature of selection for protection against the accumulation of toxic metabolic intermediates.gene cluster | gene orientation | inborn error of metabolism | secondary metabolism | specialized metabolism T here is a critical distinction between selection for a trait, which occurs at the phenotypic level, and selection of the underlying molecular genetic mechanisms that generate the trait (1). For example, some butterfly species avoid predation by mimicking the wing-pattern morphs of other butterflies that are toxic to birds (2, 3). In this case, predation avoidance selects for specific wing-pattern morphs, resulting in the selection of specific allelic combinations of genes in a supergene locus (4).The rise of molecular biology and subsequent abundance of genomic data have shifted the focus from phenotypes to genotypes, blurring the distinction between selection for and selection of. For example, many studies indicate that selection has sculpted the order and orientation of genes in eukaryotic genomes (5-13); although these analyses convincingly argue that specific genetic mechanisms are important in fine-tuning the structure of synteny on chromosomes, they implicitly assume that it is the genetic mechanisms themselves, rather than organismal phenotypes, that selection targets.One of the most conspicuous characteristics of fungal genomes is that the genes participating in a metabolic pathway are often physically linked, or clustered. Although both coordination of gene expression (5,6,(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16) and genetic linkage (7, 17) h...