“…Notice that if P is a polynomial, the composition condition reduces to the condition that P = W k for some polynomial W and k ≥ 2. Its necessity for the reducibility of L P (x, y) in the polynomial case was established by the first author in [12] (notice that this result has found applications to complex dynamics, see [11]). In Section 3.2, we show however that for rational P the reducibility of L P (x, y) = 0 does not imply in general the composition condition.…”