A gloomy picture: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials reveals disappointing effectiveness of programs aiming at preventing child maltreatment

Abstract

BackgroundConsistent findings about the effectiveness of parent programs to prevent or reduce child maltreatment are lacking.MethodsIn the present meta-analysis we synthesized findings from 27 independent samples from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on the effectiveness of 20 different intervention programs aimed at (i) preventing the occurrence of child maltreatment in the general population or with at-risk but non-maltreating families, or (ii) reducing the incidence of child maltreatment in maltreating families.ResultsA significant combined effect on maltreatment (d = 0.13; N = 4883) disappeared after the trim-and-fill approach that takes into account publication bias against smaller studies without significant outcomes. However, moderator analyses showed that larger effect sizes were found for more recent studies, studies with smaller samples, programs that provide parent training instead of only support, programs that target maltreating instead of at-risk families, and programs with a moderate length (6–12 months) or a moderate number of sessions (16–30).ConclusionsMore RCTs are needed to further unravel which factors are associated with program effectiveness. Because currently existing programs appeared to only reduce and not prevent child maltreatment, efforts in the field of preventive intervention should also focus on the development and testing of preventive programs for families at risk for child maltreatment.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12889-015-2387-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Disorganized attachment in infancy: a review of the phenomenon and its implications for clinicians and policy-makers

“…Similarly, it is notable that Loman and Siegel (2012) document substantial effects on family safety even a decade after an anti-poverty service, provided to families as part of involvement with social services, which assured that the family had reliable funds for food, clothing, and housing. However, meta-analytic data suggest that in order to be reliably successful in preventing child maltreatment, interventions may have to include parent training, and not just support (Euser, Alink, Stoltenborgh, Bakermans-Kranenburg, & van IJzendoorn, 2015). …”

Initial Findings from a Feasibility Trial Examining the SafeCare Dad to Kids Program with Marginalized Fathers

“…Parent programs aimed at preventing or reducing child maltreatment have grown over the last several decades, with findings from a recent meta-analysis demonstrating the importance of the intervention’s focus on “training” versus “support” (Euser, Alink, Stoltenborgh, Bakersman-Kraneburg, & van Ijzendoorn, 2015), especially with the highest risk families (those where maltreatment has occurred). However, data for how well parenting training and/or support programs work with fathers is limited at best (Lee et al, 2013; Osborne et al, 2016; Scourfield, 2014;).…”

A Dynamic Approach to Risk Factors for Maternal Corporal Punishment in Early to Middle Childhood

“…The authors of a recent meta-analytic review concluded that the evidence MATERNAL CORPORAL PUNISHMENT 7 of the effectiveness of preventive interventions for child maltreatment paints a gloomy picture (Euser, Alink, Stoltenborgh, Bakermans-Kranenburg, & van IJzendoorn, 2015). Universal prevention programs aside, existing interventions that prevent early CPUN are typically offered to parents based on risk factors measured at a single point in time (e.g., Zielinski, Eckenrode, & Olds, 2009).…”