A hierarchical method to automatically encode Chinese diagnoses through semantic similarity estimation

Abstract

BackgroundThe accumulation of medical documents in China has rapidly increased in the past years. We focus on developing a method that automatically performs ICD-10 code assignment to Chinese diagnoses from the electronic medical records to support the medical coding process in Chinese hospitals.MethodsWe propose two encoding methods: one that directly determines the desired code (flat method), and one that hierarchically determines the most suitable code until the desired code is obtained (hierarchical method). Both methods are based on instances from the standard diagnostic library, a gold standard dataset in China. For the first time, semantic similarity estimation between Chinese words are applied in the biomedical domain with the successful implementation of knowledge-based and distributional approaches. Characteristics of the Chinese language are considered in implementing distributional semantics. We test our methods against 16,330 coding instances from our partner hospital.ResultsThe hierarchical method outperforms the flat method in terms of accuracy and time complexity. Representing distributional semantics using Chinese characters can achieve comparable performance to the use of Chinese words. The diagnoses in the test set can be encoded automatically with micro-averaged precision of 92.57 %, recall of 89.63 %, and F-score of 91.08 %. A sharp decrease in encoding performance is observed without semantic similarity estimation.ConclusionThe hierarchical nature of ICD-10 codes can enhance the performance of the automated code assignment. Semantic similarity estimation is demonstrated indispensable in dealing with Chinese medical text. The proposed method can greatly reduce the workload and improve the efficiency of the code assignment process in Chinese hospitals.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12911-016-0269-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

ICD-10 Coding of Spanish Electronic Discharge Summaries: An Extreme Classification Problem

“…Another way to deal with lexical variability is to work directly with meanings. In this line, Chen et al have explored the Longest Common Subsequence (LCS) of concepts as a feature for the classification [10], and Ning et al have exploited the hierarchical structure using a distributional 2 https://www.asco.org/practice-guidelines/ billing-coding-reporting/icd-10/ general-equivalence-mappings-gems semantic [11]. Other approaches have applied neural networks fed with word embeddings trained on external corpora [12], [13].…”

Towards automated clinical coding

“…Several studies adopt model architectures which reflect this structure. One approach trains a binary SVM for each node in an ontology, with each classifier learning only from training examples classed as positive by its parent classifier [34,35,36,37,38]. A framework has been described for feedforward neural network training which is regularised so as to incorporate tree-based priors derived from disease ontologies [39].…”

Construction of a Semi-automatic ICD-10 Coding System

“…However, coders may code each disease separately. Third, ICD-10 codes are organized in a hierarchical structure where the top-level codes represent generic disease categories and the bottom-level codes represent more specific diseases [24], and the coder may match the diagnosis description to a generic code instead of a specific code. In addition, the coders could make obvious errors due to carelessness when the workload is heavy.…”