This article examines the student career of Dorothy M. Gladish at University College Nottingham from 1910-15. By drawing on little-studied archives, I analyse a range of narratives about Gladish's multiple embodiments of the female student. In particular, I situate these narratives within the representational contexts of the Gong student magazine, which are marked by re-writings of Victorian literary texts that re-invent the contemporary female student. In the case of Gladish, the symbolic and literal 'trial' was also a feature of her student career. I will read a 'Mock Trial' of Gladish alongside accounts of the college council's examination of Professor R. G. F. Dolley, following a complaint by the Gladish family, and their responses to the trial of Oscar Wilde in 1895, contained in a hitherto restricted archive. I will thereby consider how this case study extends our knowledge about women's roles in civic universities at this period.