Objective This study was performed to analyze the clinical, radiographic, and pathological features of hand angioleiomyoma causing nerve compression and assess the outcomes of surgical excision. Methods This case series included three men and one woman (mean age, 53.3 years; range, 49–56 years). The patients’ chief complaint was numbness of the fingers. The patients’ medical histories were reviewed, and the diagnosis of angioleiomyoma with nerve compression was confirmed by means of imaging examination and pathological analysis. Results Three tumors occurred in the palm and one in the finger, and the average maximum tumor diameter was 1.8 cm (range, 0.8–2.6 cm). Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated well-defined masses with isointense signals on T1 sequences, hyperintense signals on T2 sequences, and strong heterogeneous enhancement after injection of contrast material. All tumors were located near nerves, leading to nerve compression. The diagnosis of angioleiomyoma was confirmed by postoperative pathology. Finger sensation recovered and no recurrence was found during an average follow-up of 37 months (range, 25–59 months). Conclusions Angioleiomyoma should be considered among the differential diagnoses of hand tumors and timely resection should be performed, particularly if the mass is causing numbness and/or pain with positive Tinel’s sign and/or tenderness.