A human rights approach to advocacy for people with dementia: A review of current provision in England and Wales

Abstract

In this article, we review current advocacy services for people with dementia in England and Wales (provided, respectively, under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 , the Mental Health Act 1983 /2007 and the Care Act 2014) through the lens of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD). We examine what a human rights' approach to advocacy support would entail, and whether current frameworks in England and Wales are adequate for this approach and provide a sufficient safeguard. First, we consider how the human rights of persons with dementia have become increasingly important and the extent to which the CRPD provides an opportunity to bolster safeguards and protection. Second, we discuss cause and case advocacy, and how these advocacy models could be shaped by the CRPD to promote the rights of persons with dementia at each stage of the disease. Third, we highlight current dilemmas and challenges in the provision of advocacy support in England and Wales by focusing on case law, commissioning of services and current practice. In particular, we analyse how the different legislative schemes have given rise to some confusion about the various advocacy provisions, as well as potential for overlap and discrepancies between different regimes. We also highlight the need for further research to address important gaps in knowledge, including the scale of need, patterns of referral and attitudes to advocacy services. The article concludes by highlighting how advocacy support could be recalibrated as a universal right to promote the aims and aspirations of the CRPD, and how education is needed to address the stigma of dementia and promote the benefits of advocacy in protecting the rights of those with dementia.

<p>Facilitation of activities for people with dementia in day care: a qualitative study exploring the experiences of staff</p>

“…Thus, people with dementia are at increased risk for experiencing inequalities, injustice, marginalization, and discrimination. This is defined as a human rights issue 41,42. To be excluded from day care due to staff deciding that a person does not fit in can contribute to occupational injustice and lead to occupational deprivation.…”

“…WHO claims that human rights are often overlocked regarding people with dementia 41,42. Because of different national dementia strategies that emphasize human rights, dignity, self-respect, and the rights of the individual to choose how to live his or her own life, the research reminds us that, even in countries with policy plans, there is a gap between the plans and the everyday lived experience of the individual with dementia.…”

Measuring the well-being of people with dementia: a conceptual scoping review

“…Instruments identified in this domain are at an early stage of development; of the 16 measures that have been investigated for their psychometric properties with people with dementia only the 6-item Gratitude Questionnaire [93] relates to social well-being. However, the seven instruments included in this domain provide scope for improving the measurement of positive aspects of reciprocal interpersonal social relationships, participation, citizenship and human rights [125,126] for people with dementia.…”

Destigmatising dementia: The dangers of felt stigma and benevolent othering

“…Arguments regarding the abundant stigmatisation of dementia, and the need to tackle it, are typically invoked within overarching appeals for human rights. For example, Dixon, Laing and Valentine (2018) have recently argued:The aims of awareness raising and educational campaigns therefore should be to identify and challenge the stigma experienced by those with dementia at a societal level, as well as highlighting case advocacy as one means through which the rights of persons with dementia might be protected at an individual level. (p. 13)This political development of dementia studies has been highly beneficial for associated organisations.…”

“…Arguments regarding the abundant stigmatisation of dementia, and the need to tackle it, are typically invoked within overarching appeals for human rights. For example, Dixon, Laing and Valentine (2018) have recently argued:…”