A Hybrid Perturbation and Morris Approach for Identifying Sensitive Parameters in Surface Water Quality Models

Abstract

ABSTRACT. Surface water quality models (SWQM) are always developed as universal frameworks so that they can be flexibly employed to simulate a large variety of water bodies. These models are often over-parameterized (more parameters than needed are included in these models). As a result, it is necessary to identify sensitive parameters when these models are applied to the simulations of specific water bodies. Sensitivity analysis has been widely used as an effective tool to undertake the task. In this study, a hybrid approach was developed through integrating the parameter perturbation method and the Morris method into a general SWQMparameter sensitivity analysis framework. The approach was applied to Lake Maumelle in Arkansas with its hydrodynamics and water quality being simulated by the model CE-QUAL-W2. The sensitivities of the 96 model parameters were firstly evaluated by the parameter perturbation method in the simulation of the variables including temperature, ammonium, nitrate-nitrite, dissolved oxygen, total phosphorus and chlorophyll a, and 51 of them were found sensitive. The sensitivities of the 51 parameters were further investigated using the Morris method. It was found that each output variable was strongly sensitive to a distinctive set of parameters. It is also observed that the highly sensitive parameters display nonlinear relationships with the model outputs or strong correlations with other parameters. The obtained results from this study could provide a scientific base and solid start for the calibration, validation and application of the model.

Assessment of the Impacts of Climate Change on the Water Quality of a Small Deep Reservoir in a Humid-Subtropical Climatic Region

“…The model has the capabilities of simulating free surface elevation, pressure, density, vertical and horizontal velocities, and constituent concentration and transport [34]. W2 has been under continuous development since 1975 [33], and was particularly popular in simulating basic eutrophication processes in stratified water systems [25,26,33,35,36], such as the relationships between temperature, dissolved oxygen and algae in a natural lake [26]; and the association between organic matter and sediment in a man-made reservoir [35]. In recent years, this model has been used to evaluate the impacts of climate change on reservoir water quality to make adaptation and planning decisions for optimized water treatment plant operations [14,24].…”

A Repetitive Parameterization and Optimization Strategy for the Calibration of Complex and Computationally Expensive Process‐Based Models With Application to a 3D Water Quality Model of a Tropical Reservoir

“…The Morris is one of the global SA methods that are relatively cheap to run than alternative global SA methods such as variance‐based techniques. Morris has also been applied for water quality model calibration parameter selection in Huang (2014) and Huang and Liu (2008).…”