A lean thinking and simulation-based approach for the improvement of routing operations

Abstract

Purpose – The improvement of routing operations performance has been of great concern for organisations. This has led to the development of alternative lean-based methods, however the literature research on the applications of lean thinking in the transportation sector is still considered rather limited. The purpose of this paper is to present a lean thinking and simulation-based approach to improve the efficiency of warehousing and routing operations. Design/methodology/approach – The paper reviews the existing literature in the area of lean transportation and then presents and applies a novel approach to improve the vehicle routing operations of a Mexican firm. The proposed approach suggests the classification of wastes into those relevant to transport operations, their identification through a transportation value stream mapping study, and the use of the transportation overall vehicle effectiveness (TOVE) index for the measure of the overall performance of the transport operations. Findings – The results obtained from the case study indicate that the proposed approach is an effective alternative for the improvement of vehicle routing operations as the number of routes decreased from 30 to 22 and the distance travelled by 32 per cent. Similarly, the average number of clients served by each route increased by 23 per cent as well as the TOVE index increased from 6.9 to 19.3 per cent. The TOVE component measures of vehicle performance and operating availability efficiencies also increased significantly while quality issues, in the form of number of customers not served per route, were reduced from six to zero. Originality/value – The improvement of routing operations performance has been traditionally addressed through operations research and mathematical modelling approaches. This paper presents an alternative and novel lean thinking and simulation-based approach to improve the efficiency of routing operations.

Lean and green in the transport and logistics sector – a case study of simultaneous deployment

“…However, studies focused on the improvement of the actual road transportation operations to gain both cost (Fugate et al, 2009) and environmental efficiency through the sequential or simultaneous deployment of the lean and green paradigms is limited. The works of Sutherland and Bennett (2007), Guan et al (2003), Sternberg et al (2013), Simmons et al (2004), Villarreal (2012), Taylor and Martinchenko (2006), Hines and Taylor (2000), Villarreal et al (2012), Villarreal et al (2013), Villarreal et al (2016a), Villarreal et al (2016b) and Villarreal et al (2016c) have focused on improving road transportation through the lean paradigm, but they have not considered the green dimension. On the other hand, although some literature exists in the area of green logistics (e.g.…”

A Lean Six Sigma framework for the reduction of ship loading commercial time in the iron ore pelletising industry

“…The theoretical and industrial experience of the authors on LSS is illustrated through a wide range of reported applications and development of relevant LSS theory and research (e.g. Villarreal et al, 2016a;Villarreal et al, 2016b;Sunder and Antony, 2015;Garza-Reyes et al, 2014;Jirasukprasert et al, 2014;Garza-Reyes et al, 2010;Kumar et al, 2006;Antony et al, 2005;etc.). Finally, the third dimension included the consideration of relevant input from the company.…”

“…Sunder and Antony, 2015;Antony et al, 2007;Kumar et al, 2008), logistics (e.g. Villarreal et al, 2016a;Villarreal et al, 2016b;Sternberg et al, 2013), healthcare (e.g. Hicks et al, 2015;Gowen III et al, 2008;Cudney et al, 2013), among others.…”

A lean-TOC approach for improving Emergency Medical Services (EMS) transport and logistics operations

“…Garza-Reyes et al (2016a) implemented and combined some fundamental principles and tools of the lean and green paradigms to enhance both the environmental and operational performance of the routing operations of a world leader logistics company in Monterrey, Mexico. Villarreal et al (2016b) proposed and deployed a lean thinking and simulation-based approach to improve the efficiency of warehousing and routing operations. Garza-Reyes et al (2017) applied lean thinking to measure and drive the improvements of the road transport operations of a world leading provider of paper-based packaging solutions operating in Bogota, Colombia.…”