An effective model for predicting multicomponent aerosol evaporation in the upper respiratory system that is capable of estimating the vaporization of individual components is needed for accurate dosimetry and toxicology analyses. In this study, the performance of evaporation models for multicomponent droplets over a range of volatilities is evaluated based on comparisons to available experimental results for conditions similar to aerosols in the upper respiratory tract. Models considered include a semiempirical correlation approach as well as resolved-volume computational simulations of single and multicomponent aerosol evaporations to test the effects of variable gas-phase properties, surface blowing velocity, and internal droplet temperature gradients. Of the parameters assessed, concentration-dependent gasphase specific heat had the largest effect on evaporation and should be taken into consideration for respiratory aerosols that contain high volatility species, such as n-heptane, at significant concentrations. For heavier droplet components or conditions below body temperatures, semiempirical estimates were shown to be appropriate for respiratory aerosol conditions. In order to reduce the number of equations and properties required for complex mixtures, a resolved-volume evaporation model was used to identify a twelve-component surrogate representation of potentially toxic JP-8 fuel based on comparisons to experimentally reported droplet evaporation data. Due to the relatively slow evaporation rate of JP-8 aerosols, results indicate that a semiempirical evaporation Address correspondence to Dr. P. Worth Longest, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Virginia Commonwealth University, 601 West Main Street, P.O. Box 843015, Richmond, VA 23284-3015, USA. E-mail: pwlongest@vcu.edu model in conjunction with the identified surrogate mixture provide a computationally efficient method for computing droplet evaporation that can track individual toxic markers. However, semiempirical methodologies are in need of further development to effectively compute the evaporation of other higher volatility aerosols for which variable gas-phase specific heat does play a significant role.