'…the search for a common final pathway for schizophrenia is seductive, but may represent a misguided frame for studying the etiology.' Robert A Philibert † and Howard K Gershenfeld † Author for correspondence University of Iowa, Department of Psychiatry & Neuroscience, Room 2-126 MEB, Iowa City, IA, 52242-1000, USA Tel.: +1 319 353 4986 Fax: +1 319 353 3003 robert-philibert@uiowa.edu Expert Rev. Neurotherapeutics 7(7), 757-760 (2007) Schizophrenia is a debilitating, chronic syndrome affecting 1% of the population worldwide with compelling medical, economic and ethical reasons for improving existing treatments. Unfortunately, despite intensive efforts by the pharmaceutical industry, the current drug discovery effort for developing improved treatments for schizophrenia via a 'one drug fits all' blockbuster approach has stalled. Although the exact reasons are complex, the numerous scientific obstacles include diagnostic uncertainties, limitations of preclinical models in nonverbal animals, lack of knowledge about etiology and the complexity of this illness (reviewed in [1]).In particular, the heterogeneity of schizophrenia presents a major challenge with many etiologic routes leading to the same complex end point, a phenomenon shared with the broad syndromes of headaches, epilepsy or cancer. Schizophrenia is one label for many separate disease processes; a lesson we have come to appreciate recently for nonfamilial sporadic autism [2], which may present with similar phenotypes caused by the deletions of many different genes. Still, the search for a common final pathway for schizophrenia is seductive, but may represent a misguided frame for studying the etiology. Nonetheless, important family studies have defined the risk to first-degree relatives of patients with schizophrenia as 8-10-times the risk in the general population. Longitudinal epidemiologic studies have convincingly shown multiple environmental risk factors for schizophrenia such as time of birth (winter or urban), in utero infections, malnutrition, obstetric complications and paternal age as 1.2-5-fold risk factors. From numerous genetic studies over the last decade and the first whole genome association studies, the genetic architecture of schizophrenia and complex traits in general appears to consist of numerous small magnitude genes as risk factors individually conferring a 1.1-1.5 odds ratio [3][4][5] and updated via the schizophrenia gene website [101]. Given this reality, drug development approaches may profit from accepting that there are a multitude of pathways to psychosis, and should create personalized approaches for some of these pathways. We envision patients will benefit from a combination or cocktail of drugs similar to those now used in refractory cases of other complex disorders such as cancer, diabetes and hypertension.How can genetics contribute to this process? In general, the identification of genetic variants influencing schizophrenia can make contributions to four distinct domains:
Philibert & Gershenfeld
758Expert R...