A Meta-Analysis of the Associations Between the Nurse Work Environment in Hospitals and 4 Sets of Outcomes

Abstract

Background:The nurse work environment is theorized to influence the quality of nursing care, nurse job outcomes, and patient outcomes. Objective:The aim of this meta-analysis was to evaluate quantitatively the association of the work environment with job and health outcomes.Research Design: Relevant studies published through September 2018 were identified. Inclusion criteria were use of a nationally endorsed work environment measure and reporting of odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals from regression models of 4 outcome classes: nurse job outcomes, safety and quality ratings, patient outcomes, and patient satisfaction. Pooled ORs and confidence intervals were estimated for each outcome using fixed or random effects models.Subjects: Of 308 articles reviewed, 40 met inclusion criteria. After excluding 23 due to sample overlap or too few observations to meta-analyze, a set of 17 articles, comprising 21 independent samples, was analyzed. Cumulatively, these articles reported data from 2677 hospitals, 141 nursing units, 165,024 nurses, and 1,368,420 patients, in 22 countries.Measures: Practice Environment Scale of the Nursing Work Index, a National Quality Forum nursing care performance standard.Results: Consistent, significant associations between the work environment and all outcome classes were identified. Better work environments were associated with lower odds of negative nurse outcomes (average OR of 0.71), poor safety or quality ratings (average OR of 0.65

Healthy work environments are critical for nurse job satisfaction: implications for Oman

“…Substantial evidence demonstrated links between NWE and patient outcomes, including patient satisfaction (Lake et al 2019), and nurse outcomes including NJS (Nantsupawat et al 2017) and willingness to lead (Al Sabei et al 2019). In the Eastern Mediterranean, the topic of NWE has recently gained increasing recognition.…”

How effective response to COVID‐19 relies on nursing research

“…At the institutional level, how can hospital managers respond effectively to surging health care demand? Nursing research demonstrates that care settings value professional nursing knowledge and skill achieve better patient outcomes (Aiken et al, 2011; Lake et al, 2019). In these settings, nurses are expected and supported to fully utilize their knowledge and skill, to coordinate care within the health care team, including physicians, respiratory therapists, and unlicensed assistive personnel, and to be partners in planning for disaster response.…”

Individual nurse empowerment: A concept analysis

“…Nurses need to be empowered because despite advances toward equality, they still feel oppressed, overwhelmed, and stressed. Negative nurse work outcomes including turnover have been linked to the work environment . Current literature identifies organizational characteristics, job demands, and lack of control over the practice as components of a negative work environment affecting nurse outcomes, but does not consistently provide a deeper look at the underlying reason for these issues .…”

“…Negative nurse work outcomes including turnover have been linked to the work environment . Current literature identifies organizational characteristics, job demands, and lack of control over the practice as components of a negative work environment affecting nurse outcomes, but does not consistently provide a deeper look at the underlying reason for these issues . In a review of the past three decades of research into workplace violence, namely lateral violence, bullying, and incivility, Roberts notes that the theoretical basis for these behaviors is oppression due to hierarchy and power differentials in organizations.…”

“…Likewise, Clifford cautions against the false use of empowerment for nurses, when organizations include nurses in shared governance as a token of power without any real ability of the nurse(s) to elicit change. While shared governance has evolved and is likely more meaningful in some organizations, studies still identify a lack of control over the practice as an important contributor to nurse burnout and turnover . In a study of nurses in Iran, Sepasi, Abbaszadeh, Borhani, and Rafiei described the fluidity of power and its ability to be directed or connected to individuals, noting that although nurses did not view the job itself as being powerful, individual power was felt and expressed within the nursing team as satisfaction with work or team accomplishments.…”