A meta‐analysis on the psychological and behavioral consequences of nostalgia: The moderating roles of nostalgia activators, culture, and individual characteristics

Abstract

While previous research suggests that nostalgia can stimulate future‐oriented motivation and goal pursuit, the presence of conflicting findings complicate our understanding of the psychological and behavioral consequences of nostalgia. This study introduces and empirically validates a theoretical framework for nostalgia through a meta‐analysis of 90 effect sizes and 9757 aggregate samples from 22 experimental studies. Our findings enrich understanding of the effects of nostalgia, showing that compared to a control, nostalgia enhances consumers' sense of pleasantness, self‐continuity, attitudes, and behavioral intentions. We also identify several moderators that shape the effects of nostalgia, namely nostalgia activators, culture, and individual characteristics. Intriguingly, stronger behavioral intentions manifest in response to nostalgic events (rather than objects), realistic (over nonrealistic) scenarios, visual (as opposed to textual) priming, and female‐majority (vs. male‐majority) samples. However, we observe that long‐term (vs. short‐term) oriented cultures exhibit diminished nostalgia effects. Furthermore, we find no significant variations in responses based on age (older vs. younger), type of nostalgic experience (personal vs. collective), and sample type (students vs. nonstudents). Collectively, our meta‐analysis reveals the intricate dynamics of nostalgia, emphasizing its profound impact on consumer behavior as shaped by moderators such as nostalgia activators, culture, and individual characteristics, thereby providing a multifaceted and nuanced understanding of nostalgia.

Customer loyalty in the banking sector: a meta-analytic study

“…Ladeira et al ., 2023; Rasul et al ., 2020a, b; Rasul et al ., 2022; Santini et al. , 2020, 2023). We detailed each step applied in this research.…”

“…This approach is very common in meta-analytic studies applied to the management and marketing field (e.g. Ladeira et al, 2023;Rasul et al, 2020a, b;Rasul et al, 2022;Santini et al, 2020Santini et al, , 2023. We detailed each step applied in this research.…”

Temporal Landmarks and Nostalgic Consumption: The Role of the Need to Belong

“…For example, Chinese research often emphasizes the connection between nostalgic consumption and collective memory and a sense of security [22], which also resonates with the mediation of the need to belong in this study. However, in some western cultures, nostalgic consumption may be more closely associated with personal growth experiences and popular culture [65,66]. This difference suggests that, when designing cross-cultural marketing strategies, it is necessary to consider the cultural background of the target market and the consumers' different interpretations of time, history, and personal experiences.…”

Volunteers’ growth mindset and continuance intention: what are the roles of nostalgia and positive emotions?

“…In other words, individuals' positive emotions act as a signal for them to continue to engage in the behavior. Positive emotion is an umbrella term that encompasses a wide range of emotions, such as joy, pleasure, happiness, and hope; among them, nostalgia has garnered a growing recognition for its complex features (Wildschut et al, 2006;Sedikides et al, 2008;Barrett et al, 2010;Puente-Díaz and Cavazos-Arroyo, 2021;Santini et al, 2023). Initially known as a symptom of a medical condition (Hofer, 1934), nostalgia has advanced over the years to be labeled as a bittersweet emotion.…”