Chemical models of atmospheric particles are vital in understanding the role of aerosol particles in atmospheric chemistry, air pollution, human health, and climate change. Advancing these models requires new frameworks that can realistically predict how critical particle properties evolve. We present such a framework for predicting particle phase separation and which morphology will prevail; this controls how each particle interacts with and affects the atmosphere. We studied the mixing behavior of a-pinene secondary organic aerosol (SOA) with different organic phases, as relative humidity was varied to determine the interplay between polarity, miscibility, interfacial tension, and the resulting morphology. Using measurements from aerosol optical tweezers experiments and literature data, a general trend in morphology with increasing atmospheric oxidation was observed, from biphasic partially engulfed (where both phases are immediately accessible to the gas phase) to biphasic core shell (where the organic shell conceals the core) and finally to a single-phase, homogeneous morphology.