After reading this interesting paper the discusser was tempted to apply the theoretical equations given by the principle of natural proportionality to the experimental data contained in this paper and to gain additional experience on the common natural parameters corresponding to the crest settlement of different types of rockfill dams as well as to the one-dimensional compression tests on specimens of a rockfill-type material and the strain records with time obtained in each load step (under constant stress). where S is the settlement at the time t, S T is the total S at t ¼ 1, t à is the characteristic t at S ¼ (1=2)S T and ä is the fluidity coefficient. Equation (33) was applied to various settlement records of Fig. 1. New Fig. 17 is the same original Fig. 1 with theoretical points included. The considered cases are indicated by an arrow and the theoretical natural parameters ä, t à and S T are included in Fig. 17 for each case. Fig. 14 was used for the determination of the parameters.The general compressibility equation for soils in their first mechanical phase (unvirgin phase), before the second, more general, mechanical phase (virgin phase) reads (Juárez-Badillo, 1981)where V is the volume at stress ó , V 0 ¼ V at ó ¼ 0, (ó 1 , V 1 ) is a known point and ª is the natural coefficient of compressibility. Equation (34) may be written as (35) may be written in the simpler and elegant form, where ó à is known as the characteristic pressure Figure 16 shows the graphs of equation (34) in a form very useful in practice. Here ó 1 is the pressure needed to reduce V 0 to V 1 ¼ 0 : 9V 0 . Then the compression curves for different values of ª are as presented in Fig. 16. Equation (36) was applied to the four one-dimensional compression tests shown in Fig. 2. Fig. 18 is the same Fig. 2 with theoretical points included. The values of ª and ó à were obtained using three experimental points on each