A Neural Network Framework for Cognitive Bias

Abstract

Human decision-making shows systematic simplifications and deviations from the tenets of rationality (‘heuristics’) that may lead to suboptimal decisional outcomes (‘cognitive biases’). There are currently three prevailing theoretical perspectives on the origin of heuristics and cognitive biases: a cognitive-psychological, an ecological and an evolutionary perspective. However, these perspectives are mainly descriptive and none of them provides an overall explanatory framework for the underlying mechanisms of cognitive biases. To enhance our understanding of cognitive heuristics and biases we propose a neural network framework for cognitive biases, which explains why our brain systematically tends to default to heuristic (‘Type 1’) decision making. We argue that many cognitive biases arise from intrinsic brain mechanisms that are fundamental for the working of biological neural networks. To substantiate our viewpoint, we discern and explain four basic neural network principles: (1) Association, (2) Compatibility, (3) Retainment, and (4) Focus. These principles are inherent to (all) neural networks which were originally optimized to perform concrete biological, perceptual, and motor functions. They form the basis for our inclinations to associate and combine (unrelated) information, to prioritize information that is compatible with our present state (such as knowledge, opinions, and expectations), to retain given information that sometimes could better be ignored, and to focus on dominant information while ignoring relevant information that is not directly activated. The supposed mechanisms are complementary and not mutually exclusive. For different cognitive biases they may all contribute in varying degrees to distortion of information. The present viewpoint not only complements the earlier three viewpoints, but also provides a unifying and binding framework for many cognitive bias phenomena.

Contribution of sex on the underlying mechanism of the gambling disorder severity

“…Cognitive bias, described as an irrational, simplified, or deviated thought from "normal" decisional outcomes 63 , and in this case involving a suboptimal ability to predict gambling consequences 64 , near-misses, and an “illusion of control”, among others 65 , has been previously found to achieve the best relevance for GD severity clustering in males 13 . Both males and females showed similar levels of cognitive distortion, but while this variable mediated the weight of age of participants and impulsive traits in males on gambling activity severity, cognitive bias mediated harm avoidance and SLE effects on GD severity in females.…”

A culture of respect: Leader development and preventing destructive behavior

“…Cognitive bias, self-awareness, and critical thinking Individuals enter leadership roles with their own cognitive biases and systematic errors in thinking (Korteling et al, 2018), and they also must deal with organizational members' cognitive biases (Beshears & Gino, 2015). An awareness of these biases and their influences on decision-making processes, as well as the critical thinking skills that can combat them, will aid individuals to act with more deliberation and presence of mind when engaging in behaviors or conversations that could lead to harassment or bias.…”

Editorial to the virtual issue highlighting neuroscience based research in eating disorders to mark the 49th Society for Neuroscience Annual Meeting

“…The neuroscience of decision‐making involves neurocircuitry for learning and memory, and reward processing (Fellows, ). Cognitive or attentional biases toward likes and dislikes play an important role in this process and have been associated with distinct neural pathways (Korteling, Brouwer, & Toet, ). A study by Werthmann et al () that presented food and non‐food images on a screen showed that attention bias to food is similar in adolescents with or without anorexia nervosa; however, adults with the disorder seemed to have learned not to maintain attention, which could help restrict intake.…”