During the development of a field, many fluid samples are taken from wells. Selecting a robust fluid sample as the reservoir representative helps to have a better field characterization, reliable reservoir simulation, valid production forecast, efficient well placement and finally achieving optimized ultimate recovery. First, this paper aims to detect and separate the samples that have been collected under poor conditions or analyzed in a non-standard way. Moreover, it introduces a novel ranking method to score the samples based on the amount of coordination with other fluid samples in the region. The dataset includes 136 fluid samples from five reservoirs in Iranian fields, each of them consisting of 21 key parameters. Five acknowledged machine learning based anomaly detection techniques are implemented to compare fluid samples and detect those whose results deviate from others, indicating non-standard samples. To ensure the proper detection of outlier data, the results are compared with the traditional validation method of gas-oil ratio estimation. All five outlier detection methods demonstrate acceptable performance with average accuracy of 79% compared to traditional validation. Furthermore, the fluid samples with the highest scores in scoring-based algorithms are introduced as the best reservoir’s representative fluid. Finally, fuzzy logic is used to obtain a final score for each sample, taking the results of the six methods as input and ranking the samples based on their output score. The study confirms the robustness of the novel approach for fluid validation using outlier detection techniques and the value of machine learning and fuzzy logic for sample ranking, excelling in considering all critical fluid parameters simultaneously over traditional methods.