The method of model formulas is a new method for solving statically indeterminate reactions and deflections of elastic beams. Since its publication in the IJEE in 2009, instructors of Mechanics of Materials have considerable interest in teaching this method to enrich students' set of skills in determining beam reactions and deflections. Besides, instructors are interested in seeing relative advantages of this method versus the traditional method of superposition. This paper is aimed at comparing the method of model formulas with the method of superposition regarding (a) their methodology and pedagogy, (b) the availability of a one-page excerpt from the method of model formulas, (c) the availability of a one-page collection of deflection formulas of selected beams for the method of superposition, and (d ) assessment of their effectiveness in solving problems of reactions and deflections of beams in several identical given problems.