In the current study, prickly pear peel was advantageously recycled to preserve fruit quality. Specifically, the investigated by-products were transformed into powder and then loaded into an alginate-based solution to be applied as coating to peeled prickly pears, to give an example of sustainable minimally processed fruit. For comparison, uncoated fruit, and coated prickly pears without any powder were also prepared. During storage at refrigerated temperature, coated and uncoated samples were tested for weight loss, microbial and fungal proliferation, as well as for sensory quality acceptance. The results were interesting because great differences were found between coated and uncoated fruit, in that coating the fruit delayed weight loss and spoilage, compared to uncoated fruit. Between the simple coating and the coating with peel powder, slight differences were recorded in favor of the peel-enriched coating. In fact, it allowed the promotion of better fruit preservation, and sensory quality. Therefore, prickly pear peels, that represent abundant by-products during prickly pear processing, could be advantageously recycled to preserve fruit quality.