The interactions between aprotonic tetrabutylphosphonium carboxylate ionic liquids (ILs), [P4 4 4 4][CnCOO] (n = 1, 2 and 7), and water were investigated. The cation-anion interactions occur via the-1 H on [P4 4 4 4] + and the carboxylate headgroup of the anion. Upon addition, H2O localises around the carboxylate headgroups, inducing an electron inductive effect towards the oxygens, leading to ion-pair separation. Studies with D2O and [P4 4 4 4][CnCOO] revealed protic behaviour of the systems, with proton/deuterium exchange occurring at the-1 H of the cation, promoted by the basicity of the anion, forming an intermediate ylide. The greater influence of van der Waals forces of the [P4 4 4 4][C7COO] system allows for reorientation of the ions through larger interdigitation. The protic behaviour of the neat ILs allows for CO2 to be chemically absorbed on the ylide intermediate, forming a phosphonium-carboxylate zwitterion, signifying proton exchange occurs even in the absence of H2O. The absorption of CO2 in equimolar IL-H2O mixtures forms a hydrogen carbonate, through a proposed reaction of the CO2 with an intermediate hydroxide, and carboxylic acid.