Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and lipid hydroperoxides (LOOH) are initiators and transducers of inter- and intra-cellular signaling in response to diverse environmental, pathological and developmental cues. The accumulation of both H2O2and LOOH is often temporally and spatially coincident in tissues, but it is unknown if this coincidence extends to subcellular compartments. If distinct accumulation of different peroxides occurs at this smaller spatial scale, then it would be an important factor in signaling specificity. Fusion of the redox-sensitive (ro)GFP2 to the Saccharomyces cerevisiae (yeast) OXIDANT RECEPTOR PEROXIDASE1 (ORP1), also known as GLUTATHIONE PEROXIDASE3 (GPX3), created a now widely used biosensor that is assumed to detect H2O2in vivo. This is despite monomeric GPX enzymes, such as ORP1/GPX3, possessing wide peroxide substrate specificities. Consequently, we confirmed in vitro that roGFP2-ORP1 is not only oxidized by H2O2, but also by phospholipid fatty acid peroxides generated in lecithin-derived liposomes by lipoxygenase-catalyzed peroxidation. This led us to doubt that roGFP2-ORP1 in vivo is specific for H2O2. To address this issue of peroxide specificity, we constructed a modified biosensor called roGFP2-synORP1. This version has greatly diminished reactivity towards phospholipid fatty acid peroxides but retains high sensitivity for H2O2. These two roGFP2-based biosensors, targeted to chloroplasts, cytosol and the nucleus, were quantitatively imaged in parallel in Nicotiana benthamiana abaxial epidermal cells experiencing high light- and herbicide-induced photo-oxidative stress. From differential patterns of oxidation of these probes, we inferred that the chloroplasts accumulated both peroxide types. In contrast, LOOH and H2O2accumulated exclusively in the cytosol and nucleus respectively. Therefore, this suggests that the signalling networks initiated by different peroxides will have a distinct spatial component.