A new twist on the graduate student journal club: Using a topic‐centered approach to promote student engagement

Abstract

Journal clubs are widely used as an educational tool in graduate life science programs. In journal clubs, students are assigned to read specific journal articles to achieve a broad knowledge in their field of study and to gain competence in reading and assessing scientific publications. However, students often show low motivation to read assigned articles, and under-prepared students contribute little to in-class discussions. In order to promote student engagement in graduate-level journal clubs, we used an inverted, student-centered format that focuses on a scientific question or topic rather than specific publications. Both the weekly topics and the scientific publications were selected by the students and focused on aspects of the students' thesis research. For each weekly topic, students were asked to find papers, read the papers and summarize the findings during class, which led to the presentation of a variety of approaches and viewpoints. This approach trained students in literature search, focused reading and oral presentation skills and provided a broad overview of the research in the selected topic areas. Student feedback showed a high level of acceptance of the new format. We propose this inverted journal club format as a useful alternative to traditional formats, because it focuses on a different scientific skill set and leads to increased student engagement through its student-centered approach. K E Y W O R D Sgraduate curriculum, primary literature, student-centered

Teaching graduate research skills in genomics via an integrated ‘flipped’ journal club program

“…Several studies have attempted to formalize what makes an effective journal club program 9,10 . Of particular interest are those journal clubs that have been integrated into structured teaching programs with the aim of supporting the development of research skills to undergraduate and postgraduate student cohorts 11,12 . In all cases, the focus has been on the development of literature and presentation skills, with any formal assessment of their impact made from the perspective of post‐completion surveys and qualitative measures of self‐assessed research self‐efficacy 13 .…”

Departmental seminar series and journal club with enhanced learning outcomes

“…Progressive teaching concepts like active learning and peer-teaching could overcome such limitations. Solutions could include topic rather than paper-specific journal clubs [6] or active teaching [7], peer-mentored learning [8], which proved to increase student engagement and learning outcomes; this could potentially be further enhanced by restructuring a course into problem-solving and instruction phases [9]. Furthermore, science-related classes feature a huge variety of topics, which creates challenges and chances alike.…”

Students engage in primary literature in molecular biology techniques using an online journal club format

“…To address these challenges, we use a guided approach while allowing student choice. 2 Examples from graduate students effectively model the expectations using near-peer instruction. 3 In this way, graduate students support undergraduate students as they "teach by example."…”

“…Each term, a topic-centered approach guides students in their selection of journal articles, providing cohesiveness among the varied papers that students may choose. 2 The topic in Spring 2020 was Exosomes in Disease. This topic was selected by graduate students prior to the beginning of the term.…”

“…A challenge to this approach is that students may not be familiar with a journal club format, the scientific journal writing style, and the depth of knowledge that is needed to critically read and understand a scientific journal article. To address these challenges, we use a guided approach while allowing student choice 2 . Examples from graduate students effectively model the expectations using near‐peer instruction 3 .…”