BACKGROUND:
Recent observational and Mendelian randomization analyses have reported significant effects of very-low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (VLDL-C) on risk that is independent of ApoB.
OBJECTIVES:
To determine the independent association of VLDL-C and ApoB with the risk of new-onset cardiovascular events in the UK Biobank and the Framingham Heart Study Cohort.
METHODS:
We included 294 289 UK Biobank participants with a median age of 56 years, 42% men, and 2865 Framingham Heart Study participants (median age, 52 years; 47% men). The residual resulting from regressing VLDL-C on ApoB expresses the portion of VLDL-C not explained by ApoB, while the residual from regressing ApoB on VLDL-C expresses the portion of ApoB not explained by VLDL-C. Cox proportional hazards models for atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease incidence were created for residual VLDL-C and residual ApoB. Models were analyzed with and without high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C). Furthermore, we investigated the independent effects of VLDL-C after accounting for ApoB and HDL-C and of HDL-C after accounting for ApoB and VLDL-C.
RESULTS:
In the UK Biobank, ApoB was highly correlated with VLDL-C (r=0.70;
P
<0.001) but weakly negatively correlated with HDL-C (r=−0.11;
P
<0.001). The ApoB residual and the VLDL-C residual were significantly associated with new-onset atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (hazard ratio [HR], 1.08 and 1.06, respectively;
P
<0.001). After adjusting for HDL-C, the ApoB residual remained similar in magnitude (HR, 1.10;
P
<0.001), whereas the effect size of the VLDL-C residual was reduced (HR, 1.02;
P
=0.029). The independent effect of HDL-C (after accounting for ApoB and VLDL-C) remained robust (HR, 0.86;
P
<0.0001), while the independent effect of VLDL-C (after accounting for ApoB and HDL-C) was modest (HR, 1.02;
P
=0.029). All results were consistent in the Framingham cohort.
CONCLUSIONS:
When adjusted for HDL-C, the association of VLDL-C with cardiovascular risk was no longer clinically meaningful. Our residual discordance analysis suggests that adjustment for HDL-C cannot be ignored.