“…Schütte et al (1998) presented their data in a patent without further interpretation and without explanations regarding reproducibility. Besides Heinrich et al (2002), Radichkov et al (2006) and Dreyschultze et al (in press), a wide range of authors deal with these oscillations of PSD in simulations (for example Bück et al, 2015;Cotabarren et al, 2010;Dosta et al, 2010;Drechsler et al, 2005;Heinrich et al, 2003;Palis and Kienle, 2012;Palis and Kienle, 2014) or use them to motivate the need of process control or better models (for example Bertin et al, 2013;Cotabarren et al, 2011). But none of these references includes an experimental proof of the occurrence of PSD oscillations.…”