A participatory climate vulnerability assessment for recreational tidal flats fisheries in Belize and The Bahamas

Abstract

Recreational fishing is a pillar of the multibillion-dollar tourism sector in the Caribbean, supporting economic development and community livelihoods. However, as climate change drives increased habitat degradation, key recreational target species may experience declines. To effectively prioritize adaptation and mitigation efforts it is critical to project climate change impacts on recreational species and the communities that depend on them. We conducted a comprehensive climate vulnerability assessment (CVA) for three recreationally important tidal flats species in Belize and The Bahamas: bonefish (Albula vulpes), tarpon (Megalops atlanticus), and permit (Trachinotus falcatus). Species vulnerability was assessed by coupling 1) a research-based CVA to evaluate the sensitivity and exposure of species to climate impacts with 2) a participatory workshop involving 17 fishing guides, resource managers, and science and policy experts working in fisheries systems in Belize and/or The Bahamas. The workshop elicited local expert knowledge to resolve and contextualize CVA scoring and to identify strategies to increase climate resilience. According to the research-based CVA, key climate factors in the Caribbean are expected to see a ‘very high’ magnitude of change by 2050. All three species exhibit ‘very high’ vulnerability to these changes based on life history traits and reliance on nearshore habitats that are exposed to rapid temperature increases and storm damage. The expert stakeholder group confirmed a ‘very high’ magnitude of expected climate impacts in the Caribbean region, to which bonefish, the most valuable species, is likely to have a ‘very high’ vulnerability. However, stakeholders perceived tarpon and permit to be less vulnerable to these impacts than the CVA predicted, based on “on the water” observations of their habitat flexibility and resilience to disturbance. The group identified strategies at the individual, community, national, and international levels to enhance climate resilience in the recreational fishing sector. Our work highlights how participatory CVA processes can support a stronger understanding of species’ vulnerability while building capacity and collaboration to increase climate change readiness.

Diverse pathways for climate resilience in marine fishery systems

“…For example, research has highlighted how climate‐adaptive fisheries science and management approaches can reduce negative consequences of climate change (Bell et al, 2020; Burden & Fujita, 2019; Gaines et al, 2018; Holsman et al, 2019), but defined attributes of resilience specific to fisheries management are not clearly identified. Additionally, participatory approaches are being promoted to boost social resilience by integrating multiple perspectives and goals that extend from community to international scales (Carroll et al, 2023; Heenan et al, 2015; Mills et al, 2023). While these approaches provide options, there is a lack of clarity and synergy on how to holistically build and operationalize resilience across the natural and social dimensions of a system.…”