In this study, an optimal Tree-Seed Algorithm (TSA) algorithm-based Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controller is proposed for automatic voltage regulator (AVR) system terminal tracking problem. PID controller gains K p, K i, and K d are optimized with the proposed TSA algorithm based on different objective functions. The TSA-based optimal PID controller's performance is compared with numerous PID controllers, which were developed using different meta-hermetic optimization algorithms in the literature. Several analysis methods including root locus, bode analysis, robustness, and disturbance rejection are studied and compared with reported works in the literature. It is shown that there is still a research gap to improve the tracking performance of the AVR system due to its importance in electrical systems. According to the obtained comparison results, it has been revealed that the proposed TSA-based PID controller improves tracking properties under load change thus it can be effectively used for synchronous generator automatic voltage regulator terminal voltage stability.