In our article "6-O-and N-Sulfated Syndecan-1 Promotes Baculovirus Binding and Entry into Mammalian Cells" by Makkonen et al. in Journal of Virology (1), we investigated the interaction of baculovirus and mammalian cell surface heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPG). The data show that baculovirus requires HSPG sulfation, particularly N-and 6-O-sulfation, to bind and transduce mammalian cells. We also show that baculovirus associates specifically with syndecan-1 (SDC-1) but not with other syndecans or glypicans.As discussed in the article, HS has previously been shown to be involved in glycoprotein 64 (gp64)-mediated baculovirus binding onto mammalian cells. Heparin and heparinase I and II treatment of cells have also been shown to prevent the virus binding (2, 3). The role of HS in baculovirus entry was further studied in our article (1). Binding and baculovirus-mediated gene delivery were seen to decrease after NaClO 3 treatment, an inhibitor of sulfation. Sulfation studies also indicated that N-sulfation and 6-O-sulfation of HSPGs are important for the virus binding. Thus, it can be concluded that several studies including ours indeed support the role of HS in baculovirus interaction with mammalian cells. Since there are several HS-bearing proteins at the cell surface, we wanted to investigate further whether the virus prefers HS chains that are linked to a specific core protein. Core protein defines the type, size, amount, and orientation of the HS chains. Additionally, the core protein locates the HS chains to a specific location on the cell membrane, thus enabling, for example, the interaction with possible coreceptors. Thus, the optimal HS chain composition for virus binding can be found from specific core protein(s). The role of the core protein is equally important during virus internalization, since receptor signaling defines the entry route taken.Decreased virus entry seen by Dr. M. Nasimuzzaman in hamster pgsD-677 cells with low or severely impaired HS expression (4) supports our data well. However, even high HSPG expression/ sulfation does not guarantee efficient entry of baculovirus into cells if the virus entry and intracellular trafficking are impaired in nonpermissive cells. As stated in our article, although some cells (e.g., EA.hy926) have high HSPG/SDC-1 expression on their cell surface, the transduction rate/entry of baculovirus can be very low. This dilemma has been studied further in another one of our articles (5), in which baculovirus entry is shown to be arrested at the cell surface where the virus forms aggregates with SDC-1. Thus, the amount of HS is not necessarily directly proportional to efficient virus entry and other cellular factors such as protein kinase C phosphorylation and vimentin organization contribute to the cell susceptibility to baculovirus transduction (5).Antibody inhibition studies were performed in our article with a polyclonal rabbit SDC-1 antibody (sc-5632; Santa Cruz Biotechnology, CA). Although the antibody is against SDC-1 ectodomain and not HS, it was able to d...