A Positive and Energy Stable Numerical Scheme for the Poisson-Nernst-Planck-Cahn-Hilliard Equations with Steric Interactions

Abstract

In this work, we consider numerical methods for the Poisson-Nernst-Planck-Cahn-Hilliard (PNPCH) equations with steric interactions, which correspond to an H −1 gradient flow of a free-energy functional that consists of electrostatic free energies, steric interaction energies of short range, entropic contribution of ions, and concentration gradient energies. We propose a novel energy stable numerical scheme that respects mass conservation and positivity at the discrete level. Existence and uniqueness of the solution to the proposed nonlinear scheme are established by showing that the solution is a unique minimizer of a convex functional over a closed, convex domain. The positivity of numerical solutions is further theoretically justified by the singularity of the entropy terms, which prevents the minimizer from approaching zero concentrations. A further numerical analysis proves discrete free-energy dissipation. Extensive numerical tests are performed to validate that the numerical scheme is first-order accurate in time and second-order accurate in space, and is capable of preserving the desired properties, such as mass conservation, positivity, and free energy dissipation, at the discrete level. Moreover, the PNPCH equations and the proposed scheme are applied to study charge dynamics and self-assembled nanopatterns in highly concentrated electrolytes that are widely used in electrochemical energy devices. Numerical results demonstrate that the PNPCH equations and our numerical scheme are able to capture nanostructures, such as lamellar patterns and labyrinthine patterns in electric double layers and the bulk, and multiple time relaxation with multiple time scales. The multiple time relaxation dynamics with metastability take long time to reach an equilibrium, highlighting the need for robust, energy stable numerical schemes that allow large time stepping. In addition, we numerically characterize the interplay between cross steric interactions of short range and the concentration gradient regularization, and their impact on the development of nanostructures in the equilibrium state.

A positivity-preserving, energy stable and convergent numerical scheme for the Poisson-Nernst-Planck system

“…Furthermore, there have been a few existing works for the convergence analysis [4,31,35], while these convergence estimates have been based on the perfect Laplacian operator structure for n and p, instead of the H −1 gradient flow structure, so that the energy estimate is not available. Many other numerical schemes have been reported [13,16,27,28,33,36,40]. However, no existing work has combined the following three theoretical features in the numerical analyses: (i) unique solvability/positivity preserving property, (ii) energy stability in the variational framework, and (iii) optimal rate convergence analysis.…”