Quantum contextuality can be observed in three path interferometers, suggesting a fundamental contradiction between wave propagation and particle propagation inherent in the wave-particle dualism. Here, we investigate this contradiction in a three path interferometer specifically designed to illustrate the paradoxical aspects of single particle interference. A particularly clear violation of non-contextual assumptions is obtained when interference effects suppress detection probabilities to zero in paths that seem to be necessary to explain the observation of photons in the output. This contradiction between detection probabilities in the paths and detection probabilities in the output cannot be explained by any assignment of photon paths through the interferometer, demonstrating a fundamental incompatibility of wave propagation and particle propagation.