A qualitative study of nurses' attitudes and practices regarding brief alcohol intervention in primary health care

Abstract

Background. Excessive alcohol consumption causes significant mortality, morbidity, economic and social problems in the United Kingdom (UK). Despite strong evidence for the effectiveness of brief intervention to reduce excessive drinking in primary health care, there is little indication that such intervention routinely occurs. Aims. This study aimed to explore primary health care nurses' attitudes and practices regarding brief alcohol intervention in order to understand why it is underexploited. Methods. The study design was qualitative, using a grounded theory approach to data collection and analysis. Semi‐structured in‐depth interviews were conducted with 24 nurses from practices that had previously been involved in a General Practitioner (GP) led brief alcohol intervention trial in the North‐east of England. A combination of convenience and purposive sampling was used to recruit subjects and gain a broad range of perspectives on issues emerging from ongoing data‐analysis until data saturation occurred. Results. It was clear that although primary health care nurses have many opportunities to engage in alcohol intervention, most have received little or no preparation for this work. This has left nurses at a disadvantage as alcohol consumption is a confusing and emotive area for both health professionals and patients. An analysis of factors influencing nurse involvement in alcohol intervention outlined a requirement for clear health messages about alcohol, training in intervention skills, facilitation to enhance confidence regarding intervention and support to help deal with negative patient reactions. Conclusions. As current health policy is to encourage, sustain and extend the health promotion and public health role of primary care nurses, more attention should be given to providing them with better preparation and support to carry out such work.

A Randomized Controlled Trial of IVR-Based Alcohol Brief Intervention to Promote Patient–Provider Communication in Primary Care

“…[21][22][23][24][25] Alcoholism is stigmatized, even among health care providers, 26,27 who may expect patients to object when the topic is raised 1,28,29 and to under-report consumption and problems. 26,30 Anecdotally, we did occasionally field questions from patients about whether their provider thought they were Ban alcoholic.^Thus, a common misconception may be that a doctor would only be concerned about a patient's drinking if there was a suspected AUD. Further education of the medical community and the general public is warranted regarding the effects on medical conditions and disease management, not just AUD, that can result from exceeding the NIAAA threshold for low-risk alcohol consumption.…”

Protocol for assessing alcohol withdrawal syndrome by nursing professionals in emergency services: a pilot test

“…On specific information offered during the nursing graduate course, a study done in the late 1990s (18) , revealed among other things that alcohol and drugs were not topics of priority in the formation of nurses. More recent investigations, evaluating the knowledge obtained by nursing graduates, showed that while receiving some specific content they still had difficulty establishing interpersonal relationships with dependents (24)(25) . Acts as a script which orients attention of the professional and helps to better know the patient (define profile, demonstrate characteristics and stages, observation guide, aid in perception).…”

Association Between Receipt of Brief Alcohol Intervention and Quality of Care among Veteran Outpatients with Unhealthy Alcohol Use

“…18 Among a number of barriers to delivering brief intervention, [19][20][21][22] providers have cited concerns that patients may prefer not to discuss their drinking or may react negatively to such conversations. [19][20][21][23][24][25] In other words, providers are concerned that these discussions may compromise their relationships with patients. However, a previous study among general outpatients with unhealthy alcohol use found that those who reported receipt of brief intervention rated their care as higher quality than those not reporting brief intervention.…”