A quality improvement study of the emergency centre triage in a tertiary teaching hospital in northern Ethiopia

Abstract

IntroductionAn effective emergency triage system should prioritize both trauma and non-trauma patients according to level of acuity, while also addressing local disease burden and resource availability. In March 2012, an adapted version of the South African Triage Scale was introduced in the emergency centre (EC) of Ayder Comprehensive Specialized Hospital in northern Ethiopia.MethodsThis quality improvement study was conducted to evaluate the implementation of nurse-led emergency triage in a large Ethiopian teaching hospital using the Donabedian model. A 45% random sample was selected from all adult emergency patients during the study period, May 10th to May 25th 2015. Patient charts were collected and retrospectively reviewed. Presence and proper completion of the triage form were appraised. Triage level was abstracted and compared with patient outcome (dichotomized as “admitted to hospital or died” and “discharged alive from emergency centre”) to quantify over- and under-triage triage.ResultsFrom 251 randomly selected patients, 107 (42.6%) charts were retrieved. From these, only 45/107 (42.1%) contained the triage form filled within the chart. None of the triage forms were filled out completely. From 13 (28.9%) admitted or deceased patients, the under-triage rate was 30.7% and from 32 (71.1%) patients discharged alive from the EC the over-triage rate was 21.9%.DiscussionThe under-triage rate observed in this study exceeds the recommended threshold of 5% and is a serious patient safety concern. However, under-triage may have been magnified by irregularities in the hospital admission process. Haphazard medical record handling, poor documentation, erroneous triage decisions, and poor rapport between nurses and physicians were the main process-related challenges that must be addressed through intensive training and improved human resource management approaches to enhance the quality of triage in the emergency centre.

Effective triage in the Pacific region: The development and implementation of the Solomon Islands Triage Scale

“…time of clinician assessment and disposition) is reflective of the workload in the ED, with clinicians prioritising clinical care over data recording. Similar experience has been reported in other resource‐limited facilities implementing triage systems . Poor compliance with weight and MUAC screening for paediatric patients demonstrates that these functions are not a high priority for triage nurses.…”

“…Similar experience has been reported in other resourcelimited facilities implementing triage systems. 23 Poor compliance with weight and MUAC screening for paediatric patients demonstrates that these functions are not a high priority for triage nurses. A relatively high proportion of patients are presenting for scheduled reviews and repeat prescriptions, highlighting challenges in access to primary care.…”

Evidence in Surgery—Levels and Significance

“…An emerging new science to improve outcomes and have a win-win situation is the science of translational research and QI (quality improvement) [34]. QI research usually does not have an industry, editor and publisher interface.…”

<p>Availability of Emergency Drugs and Essential Equipment in Intensive Care Units in Hospitals of Ethiopia: A Multicenter Cross-Sectional Study</p>

“…[11][12][13][14][15] Ethiopia is one of the countries with inadequate health care facilities, equipment, human power resource, and emergency trolley guidelines. [16][17][18][19][20][21] Hospital ICUs should have immediate access to the emergency trolley. The trolley needs regular checking, maintenance, and replacement of equipment.…”