Zeolite catalysts with pronounced two‐dimensional (2D) morphologies, specifically 2D MFI nanosheets composed of multilamellar stacks of MFI nanosheets, are hypothesized to offer accessibility advantages in catalytic reactions involving large, bulky molecules. The Si/Al ratio of zeolite catalysts is an important parameter determining their performance. However, the effect of Si/Al ratio on catalytic reactivity is not well understood in 2D zeolite catalysts. To provide further insight into this issue, the catalytic performance of 2D MFI nanosheet materials with different Si/Al ratios is compared using the liquid phase Friedel‐Crafts alkylation of mesitylene with benzyl alcohol & the self‐etherification of benzyl alcohol that occurs in parallel, both of which are catalyzed by Brønsted acid sites. The turnover frequency (TOF) of the catalysts is found to decrease with decreasing Si/Al ratio, with the etherification reaction being the main contributor to this trend. When the same reaction is carried out in the presence of a bulky poison, 2,6 di‐tert‐butylpyridine (DTBP), to selectively deactivate the external acid sites, only the etherification reaction of benzyl alcohol takes place in the micropores of the 2D MFI catalyst and the effectiveness factor is found to decrease with decreasing Si/Al ratio. The single component adsorption isotherms of benzyl alcohol show that the uptake normalized per acid site decreases with decreasing Si/Al ratio. Thus, increasing the density of acid sites in the micropores by decreasing the Si/Al ratio makes it more difficult for the reactant molecules to access them, as demonstrated by the decrease in TOF and the effectiveness factor. While the micropore reactions (benzene alkylation, alcohol etherification) showed a clear trend with Si/Al ratio, the reaction catalyzed on the external surface (mesitylene alkylation) did not, showing distinct differences in reactivity.