Two types of aspartyl-tRNA synthetase exist: the discriminating enzyme (D-AspRS) forms only Asp-tRNA Asp , while the nondiscriminating one (ND-AspRS) also synthesizes Asp-tRNA Asn , a required intermediate in protein synthesis in many organisms (but not in Escherichia coli). On the basis of the E. coli trpA34 missense mutant transformed with heterologous ND-aspS genes, we developed a system with which to measure the in vivo formation of Asp-tRNA Asn and its acceptance by elongation factor EF-Tu. While large amounts of Asp-tRNA Asn are detrimental to E. coli, smaller amounts support protein synthesis and allow the formation of up to 38% of the wild-type level of missense-suppressed tryptophan synthetase.Aspartyl-tRNA synthetase (AspRS) exists in two different forms with respect to tRNA recognition (7). The discriminating enzyme (D-AspRS) recognizes only tRNA Asp , while the nondiscriminating one (ND-AspRS) also recognizes tRNA Asn and therefore forms both Asp-tRNA Asn and Asp-tRNA Asp . Most bacteria and archaea lack asparaginyl-tRNA synthetase and are unable to synthesize Asn-tRNA Asn by direct acylation of tRNA. These organisms rely on the ND-AspRS to produce the misacylated Asp-tRNA Asn , which is then converted by a tRNA-dependent amidotransferase to the correctly acylated Asn-tRNA Asn (1,4,5,19). Thus, the ND-AspRS is essential in organisms that form Asn-tRNA by transamidation.The primary sequence distinguishes two general groups of AspRS. There is a predominantly bacterial type of AspRS that is about 580 amino acids, in addition to a shorter archaealeukaryotic type of about 430 amino acids. In vitro data have made clear that discriminating and nondiscriminating enzymes exist in both groups (16,20). The determinants in the protein sequence responsible for tRNA discrimination are not known.The two AspRS types are usually separated in nature. Genome analyses of bacteria and archaea have revealed that the presence of the ND-AspRS is always accompanied by the occurrence of the heterotrimeric GatCAB amidotransferase, an enzyme capable of converting the misacylated Asp-tRNA Asn to Asn-tRNA Asn (2,5,19). Presumably, this is to avoid introducing the misacylated Asp-tRNA Asn into an organism's translational apparatus and potentially endangering protein synthesis. This reasoning is supported by the fact that the heterologous expression of ND-AspRS or ND-GluRS in Escherichia coli, which lacks GatCAB, is highly toxic to the cell, especially when the synthetase genes are overexpressed (15). However, some organisms (e.g., Deinococcus radiodurans and Thermus thermophilus) contain a D-AspRS in addition to an ND-AspRS and a GatCAB amidotransferase (1,3,5,9).We wanted to observe how E. coli copes with in vivo mischarging effected by the ND-AspRS, as this organism is unable to eliminate the toxic Asp-tRNA Asn . Therefore, we developed an approach that would, in fact, require E. coli to be dependent on the presence of mischarged Asp-tRNA Asn for growth. To this aim, we used missense suppression of a specific mutation in the trp...