(1) Background: Retroareolar breast tumors, although common, rarely develop into malignancies. This case report presents the case of a 54-year-old woman with a superficial breast tumor, high-lighting the significance of considering a wide range of possibilities when evaluating breast lumps. (2) Methods: The patient presented with a progressively enlarging, ulcerating superficial mass in her left breast. To determine the nature of the tumor and results confirmed the presence of a Grade II superficial infiltrating ductal carcinoma. To address the condition, the patient un-derwent a modified radical mastectomy under general anesthesia. Following the surgery, she was prescribed tamoxifen, an estrogen receptor modulator, in accordance with the current guidelines. (3) Results: The patient experienced a smooth recovery without any complications and displayed no signs of recurrence or metastasis during follow-up visits. This positive outcome highlights the importance of early detection and proactive management in improving patient prognosis. (4) Conclusions: This case report underscores the significance of conducting a comprehensive ex-amination and maintaining a high index of suspicion for breast lumps. This report contributes to the existing body of literature on the diverse presentations of breast cancer.