A realist evaluation of the management of a well- performing regional hospital in Ghana

Abstract

BackgroundRealist evaluation offers an interesting approach to evaluation of interventions in complex settings, but has been little applied in health care. We report on a realist case study of a well performing hospital in Ghana and show how such a realist evaluation design can help to overcome the limited external validity of a traditional case study.MethodsWe developed a realist evaluation framework for hypothesis formulation, data collection, data analysis and synthesis of the findings. Focusing on the role of human resource management in hospital performance, we formulated our hypothesis around the high commitment management concept. Mixed methods were used in data collection, including individual and group interviews, observations and document reviews.ResultsWe found that the human resource management approach (the actual intervention) included induction of new staff, training and personal development, good communication and information sharing, and decentralised decision-making. We identified 3 additional practices: ensuring optimal physical working conditions, access to top managers and managers' involvement on the work floor. Teamwork, recognition and trust emerged as key elements of the organisational climate. Interviewees reported high levels of organisational commitment. The analysis unearthed perceived organisational support and reciprocity as underlying mechanisms that link the management practices with commitment.Methodologically, we found that realist evaluation can be fruitfully used to develop detailed case studies that analyse how management interventions work and in which conditions. Analysing the links between intervention, mechanism and outcome increases the explaining power, while identification of essential context elements improves the usefulness of the findings for decision-makers in other settings (external validity). We also identified a number of practical difficulties and priorities for further methodological development.ConclusionThis case suggests that a well-balanced HRM bundle can stimulate organisational commitment of health workers. Such practices can be implemented even with narrow decision spaces. Realist evaluation provides an appropriate approach to increase the usefulness of case studies to managers and policymakers.

Understanding the factors that make public participation effective in health policy and planning: a realist synthesis

“…Burton et al (2006) have proposed this approach to evaluate public participation; they consider its potential in bringing to the surface key assumptions about how public participation is expected to make a difference. The appropriateness of this realist approach has been demonstrated by its use in the evaluation of complex systems such as complicated interventions and programs (Marchal et al 2010). This fairly new approach to literature synthesis has been increasingly used to understand programs or interventions, with the primary argument that no one particular intervention fits all situations because of its contextual dependence.…”

Empowering change: Realist evaluation of a Scottish Government programme to support normal birth

“…Realist evaluation has been used in a wide range of healthcare evaluations including individual healthcare interventions aimed at patient/practitioner behaviours (Rycroft-Malone et al, 2010, Fairhurst et al 2005, Tolson et al, 2007, local-level changes to healthcare delivery (Wand et al, 2011, Marchal et al, 2010, Byng et al, 2005 and large scale programmes of health service change (Greenhalgh et al, 2009, Evans & Killoran, 2000, Kennedy et al, 2005. This approach to evaluation has resulted in deeper insights into why a programme/intervention did or did not work and what contextual factors were associated with outcomes.…”

“…This approach to evaluation has resulted in deeper insights into why a programme/intervention did or did not work and what contextual factors were associated with outcomes. Through its focus on understanding why change occurs (or not) and in which conditions, realist evaluation allows decision-makers to draw transferrable lessons about effective implementation strategies, thereby lending greater external validity to the findings (Marchal et al, 2010).…”

Challenge Demcare: management of challenging behaviour in dementia at home and in care homes – development, evaluation and implementation of an online individualised intervention for care homes; and a cohort study of specialist community mental health care for families

“…326 This may help the researcher to elucidate what might work for whom and in what clinical context. Realist evaluation is an emerging area of enquiry that has strong potential for informing research questions that take into account the different contexts of delivery on health-care innovation and interventions, and show scope for refined approaches to process evaluation in applied health-care research 327,328 and training. 327,329,330 Challenging behaviour in dementia care home and family care settings: a comparison of clinical presentations…”