A reflection on the use of case studies as a methodology for social learning research in sub Saharan Africa

Abstract

A recent review has highlighted that the methodology most commonly employed to research social learning has been the individual case study. We draw on four examples of social learning research in the environmental and sustainability sciences from sub-Saharan Africa to reflect on possible reasons behind the preponderance of case study research in this field, and to identify common elements that may be significant for social learning research more generally. We find that a common interest in change oriented social learning, and therefore processes of change, makes case studies a necessary approach because long term process analyses are required that are sensitive to social-ecological contexts. Common elements of the examples reflected upon included: a focus on initiating, tracking and/or understanding a process of change toward sustainability; long term research; an action research agenda that involves reflecting on data with research participants; and temporal, process based analysis of data coupled with in-depth theoretical analysis. This paper highlights that there is significant scope for exploratory research that compares case studies of social learning research to generate a deeper understanding of social learning processes, and their relationship to human agency and societal change.

Social learning and climate change adaptation: evidence for international development practice

“…As Box illustrates, these stakeholders called for increased local participation to provide opportunities for information sharing and knowledge building, identifying that adaptation should stimulate behavioral change and socio‐institutional shifts. As one respondent surveyed for the study noted, there is a need for ‘tools and methodologies… that help people adapt and do things differently.’ The views expressed by these stakeholders resonate with a growing literature linking climate change adaptation, development, and social learning . Many authors highlight the contrast between the social learning paradigm and policies that focus on behavior change through regulating, informing, or educating actors.…”

Unraveling the Relationship between Collective Action and Social Learning: Evidence from Community Forest Management in Canada

“…In other words, action is not the only measure of effective social learning. In fact, "social learning research is change-oriented and most often interested in how social learning unfolds or is mediated and how it can influence action and adaptation" [37] (p. 45). The many criticisms of social learning in the learning literature for lacking a clear focus, providing empirical evidence to support or refute the theory's many assertions, and assumptions related to learning leading to collective action, can only help strengthen the theory.…”

Fostering Learning in Large Programmes and Portfolios: Emerging Lessons from Climate Change and Sustainable Development

“…As a result, we have opted for a case study approach to analysis, with the added dimension of using nested case studies to enhance comparability across scales [48]. Comparative case study design is said to be particularly useful in contexts "where the intention is not just to describe a situation, but to analyse and interpret results in such a way that generates questions or propositions for further research" [49] (p. 44). The nested nature of the cases allows for analysis that is both horizontal (across cases) and vertical (from lower-to higher-order programmes) [48].…”