A reflexive exploration of two qualitative data coding techniques

Abstract

In an attempt to help find meaning within qualitative data, researchers commonly start by coding their data. There are a number of coding systems available to researchers and this reflexive account explores my reflections on the use of two such techniques. As part of a larger investigation, two pilot studies were undertaken as a means to examine the relative merits of open coding and template coding for examining transcripts. This article does not describe the research project per se but attempts to step back and offer a reflexive account of the development of data coding tools. Here I reflect upon and evaluate the two data coding techniques that were piloted, and discuss how using appropriate aspects of both led to the development of my final data coding approach. My exploration found there was no clear-cut 'best' option but that the data coding techniques needed to be reflexively-aligned to meet the specific needs of my project. This reflection suggests that, when coding qualitative data, researchers should be methodologically thoughtful when they attempt to apply any data coding technique; that they do not assume pre-established tools are aligned to their particular paradigm; and that they consider combining and refining established techniques as a means to define their own specific codes.

The voices of death doulas about their role in end‐of‐life care

“…Descriptive statistics were performed on the closed‐ended questions to summarise and analyse the quantitative data and are reported as number of respondents ( n ) and proportion (%) (IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 25.0.: IBM Corp). Data from free‐text answers were determined a priori due to the categorical nature of the survey questions, which captured what needed to be answered (Blair, ). As a result, the qualitative comments served to support and provide clarification of what had emerged in the survey, rather than being theory driven (Whitehead, Dilworth, & Higgins, ).…”

E‐government implementation and monitoring: The case of Rwanda's ‘one‐stop’ E‐government

“…In this qualitative exploratory study, we adopted “template analysis” as the method for data analysis. It is a form of thematic analysis also referred to as template coding (Blair, ). The method consists of developing template codes about the subject of research.…”

“…They are formed on the basis of a subset of data and are applied to further data, then revised and refined (Brooks, McCluskey, & Turley, E. &King N., ). However, Blair () indicates that template codes can also be drawn from literature or theory.…”

College Student Writers' Use and Modification of Planning and Evaluation Strategies After a Semester of Instruction

“…Codes were inductively developed based on the taught strategies, the modifications mentioned by students in the think‐aloud, and other comments during the task (Strauss & Corbin, ). We applied Blair's () guidelines on a priori and emergent coding. Codes were developed by Zoi and applied to all cases (see Table ).…”