A reinterrogation of South African child welfare discourse: A case for decolonisation?

Abstract

Relying on discourse analysis and critical social work, this article explores the relevance of a decolonisation discourse to South African child welfare. A child welfare discourse of coloniality emerges from Australia, New Zealand and Canada. This emphasises the role that colonisation has played in eradicating indigenous persons or alternately assimilating subjugated populations to Western norms and sensibilities and maintains that coloniality persists in contemporary child welfare. South African child welfare has not been explicitly problematised as furthering coloniality. There have been transformation efforts post-apartheid relating to the legislative/policy environment and increasing racial representation and community-based access. However, the colonial and apartheid roots of South African child welfare persist in impacting child welfare, particularly by overriding local ways of being. A decolonisation discourse is needed to identify the various ways in which the child welfare system replicates colonising processes and how these can be interrupted. To do so, the individualised, intrusive, punitive, statutory Child Protection discourse must be replaced, structural issues prioritised, intergenerational and contemporary trauma centred, liberatory indigenous child-rearing practices privileged and local knowledges curated and used to inform the child welfare process.

Gendered and Racialised Epistemological Injustice in FGM-safeguarding

“…Furthermore, distinguishing between generations within families was also key to colonial policy interventions seeking to save and civilize (Cunneen, 2008). Most notably, child removal policies were in operation in multiple colonies, and for many decolonial scholars, effectively remain ongoing given the disproportionate numbers of indigenous children taken into state care (Mohamud et al, 2021; Nyamu and Wamahiu, 2022; Schmidt, 2022).…”