A research on syndrome element differentiation based on phenomenology and mathematical method

Abstract

BackgroundAs an empirical medical system independent of conventional Western medicine (CWM), over thousands of years, traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) has established its own unique method of diagnosis and treatment. The perspective of holism and system in TCM is essentially different from the view of Reductionism in CWM. With the development of modern science and technology, the restriction of reductionism is more and more prominent, and researchers begin to pay more attention to holistic thinking in TCM. Confronted with the above situation, there is an urgent need to explore the diagnosis of TCM by the techniques of modern science.MethodsTo explore the feasibility of using modern science to describe and realize the diagnosis of TCM, in this paper, a method of syndrome element differentiation based on phenomenology is proposed. The proposed method is implemented by mathematical mapping, and then it is testified through analysis of 670 medical records: Based on the original mapping data between two data sets (set of syndrome elements and set of clinical manifestations), new mapping data is generated, and thus the corresponding quantitative diagnostic results are calculated and evaluated. Finally, knowledge discovery of the diagnosis results based on attribute partial-ordered structure diagram is conducted.ResultsThe value order’s matching results between original and new results show that the matched degree of each record is no less than 65%, while there are at least 87% records whose matched degree is more than 80%. In addition, the knowledge discoveries of new results are basically identical with the ones of original results as well.ConclusionUsing phenomenology to describe syndrome differentiation should be feasible, and further research on mapping relations between various sets (symptoms, formulas, drugs) of TCM should be conducted and evaluated through clinical trials in future.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13020-017-0141-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

The RIGHT Extension Statement for Traditional Chinese Medicine: Development, Recommendations, and Explanation

“…For item 6 (S2 in the checklist of the RIGHT-TCM), it is recommended to describe the principle and method of TCM treatment in the recommendations section. These general principles and basic methods for treating diseases are based on the unique concept of holism and syndrome differentiation and have guiding significance for the specific treatment measures in traditional Chinese medicine [ 22 ]. For item 7 (S3 in the checklist of the RIGHT-TCM), it is recommended to describe whether to treat disease based on the syndrome differentiation of TCM.…”

The Causality Research between Syndrome Elements by Attribute Topology

“…The experimental data in this paper are from the clinical data, collected by the team of Hong [ 39 ]. In the system, for the clinical manifestations mapping to syndrome elements, 177 inquiry questions (related to symptoms or signs common in clinical diagnosis) are designed for males, while 194 inquiry questions are designed for females.…”

Evidence‐based traditional Chinese medicine research: Two decades of development, its impact, and breakthrough

“…This has been evidenced by the development from the RCT design, to a classic MA and to a network MA. The ever‐enriching methods will help solve more complicated problems and change our understanding of the value of data 93–98 …”