A Review of Arguments for the Existence of Latent Infections of Bacillus anthracis, and Research Needed to Understand Their Role in the Outbreaks of Anthrax

Abstract

Hugh-Jones and Blackburn and Turnbull’s collective World Health Organization (WHO) report did literature reviews of the theories and the bases for causes of anthrax outbreaks. Both comment on an often-mentioned suspicion that, even though unproven, latent infections are likely involved. Hugh-Jones suggested Gainer do an updated review of our present-day knowledge of latent infections, which was the basis for Gainer’s talk at the Biology of Anthrax Conference in Bari, Italy 2019. At the Conference Gainer met Vergnaud who presented anthrax genome studies that implied that the disease might have spread throughout Asia and from Europe to North America in a short time span of three or four centuries. Vergnaud wondered if latent infections might have played a role in the process. Several other presenters at the Conference also mentioned results that might suggest the existence of latent infections. Vergnaud subsequently looked into some of the old French literature about related observations, results, and discussions of early Pasteur vaccine usage (late 1800′s) and found mentions of suspected latent infections. The first part of the paper is a focused summary and interpretation of Hugh-Jones and Blackburn’s and Turnbull’s reviews specifically looking for suggestions of latent infections, a few additional studies with slightly different approaches, and several mentions made of presentations and posters at the Conference in Italy. In general, many different investigators in different areas and aspects of the anthrax study at the Conference found reasons to suspect the existence of latent infections. The authors conclude that the affected species most studied, including Homo sapiens, provide circumstantial evidence of latent infections and modified host resistance. The last part of the review explores the research needed to prove or disprove the existence of latent infections.

An Outbreak of Human Systemic Anthrax, including One Case of Anthrax Meningitis, Occurred in Calabria Region (Italy): A Description of a Successful One Health Approach

“…Another important aspect emerging from this episode is the role of subclinical forms of anthrax in animals [ 32 ] since the slaughtered bullock, as referred by the farmer, didn’t show evident clinical signs of anthrax when alive. Based on this, a subclinical form cannot be excluded.…”

JMM Profile: Bacillus anthracis

“…Animal outbreaks probably reflect these factors, plus in some cases biting fly transmission [1,18,43,56]. Some disease patterns are puzzling [36,56] and it is plausible that immunity [43,57] and latency or subclinical disease [58] could have significant influence. Sporadic (non-enzootic) cases often follow soil disturbances [8].…”

An update on emerging therapeutics to combat COVID‐19

“…Telemedicine involves the use of information technology for providing expert advice from a distance 186 . Face‐to‐face contact plays an essential role in patient and doctor relationship 187 .…”